football.london

Arsenal sent clear penalty verdict after VAR controversy left Mikel Arteta demanding answers

Arsenal were left complaining about the decision not to be awarded a penalty during their win over Hull City at the Emirates Stadium on Saturday

Mikel Arteta

Mikel Arteta was furious with the decision

View Image

Arsenal should have been awarded a penalty against Hull City, despite Kai Havertz being ruled offside in the build-up.

‌

‌

That's the view of former Premier League referees' chief Keith Hackett and ex-assistant referee Darren Cann. The Gunners secured a narrow 1-0 victory over Hull on Saturday afternoon to strengthen their grip on top spot in the Premier League, although the result was overshadowed by a controversial VAR decision.

‌

Mikel Arteta's side recorded their fifth consecutive league win and ninth victory in 10 matches, with Martin Odegaard's 72nd-minute strike proving decisive. However, Arsenal could have broken the deadlock much earlier after a contentious first-half incident left the home supporters and players frustrated.

‌

The hosts initially thought they had won a penalty when Havertz was brought down inside the area by Hull defender Nobel Mendy. Referee Farai Hallam pointed to the spot, sparking celebrations around the Emirates Stadium, before VAR intervened and ruled that the German had strayed offside in the build-up.

Make sure you never miss the latest Arsenal news and opinion by making Football London one of your Google preferred sources.

The decision saw the penalty overturned and Hull awarded a free-kick instead, much to the frustration of the Arsenal players and supporters. Arteta was visibly furious on the touchline as his side headed towards the interval without a breakthrough, despite dominating proceedings throughout a frustrating opening 45 minutes.

‌

"I don’t know, I haven’t watched it back,” the Arsenal boss said afterwards. "I didn’t watch it back so I don’t have to lie to you guys. I was surprised, because when they sent the referee to the monitor the bench was telling me that it’s a clear penalty, it’s pulling.

"I know they decided not to because the starting position of Kai was offside, so I don’t know what the interpretation is. I’m sure they will make that clear to understand it."

‌

VAR spent several minutes reviewing the incident before instructing Hallam to consult the pitchside monitor. The referee was informed that Mendy had pulled Havertz's shirt, but because the Arsenal forward was deemed offside, the challenge could not result in a penalty.

FOLLOW OUR ARSENAL FB PAGE!Latest Gunners news, analysis and much more via our dedicated Facebook page

‌

However, former referee chief Hackett disagreed with the decision and made his feelings clear in a post on X, writing: "The Offside Law is clear and a penalty kick should have been awarded."

Meanwhile, Cann offered his verdict on Match of the Day, explaining why he believed Arsenal should have been awarded a penalty.

‌

He said: "I'll do my best but it's a very complicated part of law 11, offside. The foul should have taken precedence and it should have been a penalty kick rather than an offside. We can see that Kai Havertz is clearly in an offside position, he's having his shirt pulled by Mendy but they're not actually challenging for the ball.

Content cannot be displayed without consent

‌

"That's why the foul should take precedence over the offside because Kai Havertz hasn't committed an offside offence at this moment in time when he's being fouled. So they're too far away from the ball, that should really have been a given as a penalty kick for a shirt pull in strict accordance with law because there is no offside offence until he actually engages and challenges for the ball.

"I think the law is ambiguous, it's very hard to follow for match officials as well as for the public, for the fans. I personally think that if a player is in an offside position and they make a movement towards the ball, I would prefer to prioritise the offside rather than a foul and I think everyone knows where they stand."

Article continues below

Arsenal's victory, coupled with Manchester City's defeat at Nottingham Forest, has seen the Gunners open up a six-point lead at the top of the Premier League table.

Read full news in source page