I’ve taken quite a number of standardized tests in my life. Starting from elementary school, then all through middle and high school, multiple times during my college years, and even after I had earned my graduate degree, the entirety of my academic career was littered with these exams. Generally, I did pretty well — I’ve always been a fairly reliable test-taker. But even for me, things got harder and harder the further I progressed in my education.
Obviously, that’s not too surprising. The material gradually became more difficult to understand, and more application of critical thinking was demanded of me. Regurgitation of memorized concepts didn’t cut it anymore after high school.
But that isn’t the only reason why the standardized tests I sat for grew harder. The knowledge required was one thing, sure. However, over time that became less the crux of the matter and more a simple prerequisite for attempting the feat to begin with.
In reality, the true challenge of these later assessments was the fortitude necessary to complete them. Aptitude and entrance exams typically take several hours. Licensure exams can be multi-day affairs. And for all that time, you are expected to maintain heightened focus with only a few breaks allowed and just enough time allotted for you to finish if you work at a solid clip.
It feels laughable to say this about sitting at a desk and filling in a Scantron sheet, but in a way it’s grueling. If you’re taking the bar exam or sitting for your boards after medical school or something else of that nature, you are effectively being asked to exercise the best memory recall of your life, apply that knowledge effectively to various scenarios, and reach the correct conclusion over and over again, for several hours, without much in the way of interruption. For the bar and other assessments, you then have to come back the next day and do it again.
What often occurs is that near the end of these tests, you are putting out a work product that is far from your best. By the time you reach the final stretch, your mind is tired — the facts you memorized are fuzzier in your recollection, your brain’s computing power is depleted, and your attention to detail is declining. Even the easy questions begin to feel like potential banana skins.
In this era of the Premier League, when elite football teams like Arsenal are playing every three days, I feel like a similar phenomenon occurs. The top of the sport is attritional now. Game come in blocks, and almost every game requires maximum effort and focus. And some blocks are especially grueling.
Over several weeks this is massively draining, even for the finest players and coaches on the planet. The intense physicality, the tactical nuances, the constant need for composure… these are titanic burdens to sustain over such long stretches of time. Eventually, winning becomes more important than winning with style.
Much to the chagrin of the rest of the world, Arsenal have become quite good at adapting to these conditions to get results over the line, even when the business end of a demanding weeks-long schedule has them operating below their best. It isn’t pretty, but it is effective. Which is the most important thing in a footballing landscape that ensures perfection is more unattainable than ever.
That was evident when Hull City came to the Emirates Stadium on Saturday. Although the Tigers never threatened a mauling, they were organized and resolute, pressing their hosts aggressively and defending well enough to keep the Gunners at bay. Arsenal for their part were flat for much of the match; three consecutive away trips and five of their last six games in all competitions being on the road clearly had taken their toll. Despite dominating possession, Mikel Arteta’s men were ponderous going forward and inefficient in their final action.
But eventually, they found a way to win. Despite the tiredness, despite the clear lack of sharpness, Martin Ødegaard bundled in a rebound from a Noni Madueke shot and the English champions did what they do best: defend a narrow lead. Arsenal secured a 1-0 victory as Manchester City went to Nottingham Forest and succumbed to their third successive league defeat. The weekend’s results now mean that the Gunners enter the international break with a five-point lead at the top of the Premier League table.
Was it perhaps a forgettable victory? Sure. Should the Gunners run up the score a little more against newly promoted opposition? Probably. But Chelsea — who were deemed potential title challengers to start the season — drew at home to Hull two months ago. Arsenal, after traveling to Forest, Bayern Munich, Fleetwood Town, Liverpool, and Slavia Praha in quick succession over the last few weeks, got the job done. They did what they needed to do to pass the test before them. And at the end of the day, getting the answer right is more important than how eloquently you write it.
The Non-Negotiables is a reader-supported publication. To support my work, please consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. The paid subscription is more of a “tip jar” option; there are no additional benefits, you would just be exercising your generosity. Either way, I am grateful for your readership.
Subscribe
Ballers
Noni Madueke
He continues to go from strength to strength. If he had shot first-time when he was played in on goal by Mikel Merino in the 87th minute instead of taking an extra touch and losing possession, it may have been a complete performance from the Englishman. In any event, Madueke was Arsenal’s most threatening attacker against Hull. Time and time again, he ran the visitors’ left side ragged and was the focal point of attacks.
Madueke accumulated 14 touches in the opposition box, the most of any player in the match. He attempted four shots, joint-most in game. And he completed six dribbles, again most in the match. He also created four chances, and completed 40 of 47 passes. His decision-making was terrific and maybe it’s just me, but his quality on the ball appears to be improving too.
Ultimately, it was Madueke’s shot in the 72nd minute that led to the winner. The winger made his way into Hull’s penalty area and cut in on his left foot before fizzing in a knuckleball towards the visitors’ goal. Konstantinos Tzolakis, who’d had a frustratingly impressive game up until that point, parried the shot right into Ødegaard’s path and the Arsenal skipper tapped in the game’s only goal.
Madueke is consistently making things happen as he fills in for Bukayo Saka. He isn’t just Arsenal’s most improved player this season, he has been one of their best performers of late. He is probably hugely disappointed to have missed out on the England squad for this international break, but two weeks’ rest for him might make this a blessing in disguise.
Martin Ødegaard
The Arsenal captain was great against Hull. Ødegaard managed 99 touches on Saturday, and was one of the central driving forces as the Gunners tried to break the visitors down. He made 22 line-breaking passes and 11 passes into the final third. His intent on progressing the ball forward was perhaps why he only completed 67 of 82 passes, a lower percentage than you typically get from the Norwegian.
Ødegaard was probably the champions’ most creative player on the day. He produced five chances, the most of the match. On one occasion, Ødegaard attempted to play Christos Tzolis in behind and the Greek won a free kick in a threatening position. But perhaps the biggest chance the skipper created was when he slipped Kai Havertz in behind Hull’s back line and the German was in on goal. All things considered, Ødegaard probably should have walked away with an assist.
However, he did finish the match with a goal contribution. In the 72nd minute, he pounced after Madueke’s shot was saved and knocked home the rebound. His attacking instinct has improved this season, and he now boasts five goals in all competitions. The Gunners will need him to keep up his scoring form.
Bruno Guimarães
Guimarães also had a good showing against Hull. The Brazilian was heavily involved in proceedings, amassing a whopping 111 touches. Like Ødegaard, he tried keenly to move the ball up the pitch. Guimarães finished with 29 line-breaking passes, eight passes into the final third, and three of four long balls successful.
In particular, I was really impressed with his composure in buildup. When he arrived with Newcastle, Guimarães sporting one of the best passing percentages under pressure in the English top flight and that showed on Saturday. Hull pressed rather aggressively as Arsenal attempted to play out from the back, and yet the Brazilian strung together passes efficiently and combined well with Ødegaard to kept things ticking over.
I also continue to be highly impressed by Guimarães’ engine. His heatmap shows a player that was immensely active in all of the thirds. In addition to his involvement on the ball Guimarães ended the match with three tackles, two clearances, and two recoveries. He also won five of seven ground duels and was not dribbled past. The summer signing has plenty of room to improve, but it was another all-action performance from him.
Fallers
Christos Tzolis
When Tzolis arrived at Arsenal, the thing I was most excited about was his final third efficiency. To me, the Greek’s superpower was making the correct decision in opposition territory with regularity. Unfortunately, the performance we got from Tzolis on Saturday did not follow that modus operandi.
Tzolis did take the joint-most shots in the game, but none of them were particularly threatening. The former Club Brugge man did put two on target, but both his header from close range and an attempt from the left side of Hull’s penalty area were rather tame. When he latched onto a cross from Madueke that went to the middle of Hull’s penalty area, he booted it closer to the concourse that to the goal. Tzolis had crosses that didn’t make it past the first defender and one that looped well over Arsenal’s man at the back post.
Perhaps his most frustrating moment was on the break early in the match. He led the charge on the counter with Havertz free on the left wing just beyond them. However, Tzolis dallied, opting to dribble between two defenders rather than play the easy ball and predictably losing possession. It just wasn’t his day.
Kai Havertz
I had hoped that his winner at Anfield would spark a return to form for Havertz. Unfortunately, that didn’t appear to be the case against Hull. I’ve heard Clive Palmer from the Arsenal Vision Podcast describe him as “anemic” a couple times recently, and I think that’s a pretty good way to put it. When he’s not up for the physical battle in a match, the German can appear rather lightweight. And so he did on Saturday.
Against Hull, it just felt like he was going to ground a little easily. To be fair, Havertz was unlucky not be to awarded a penalty for going down after his shirt was pulled by Nobel Mendy in the Tigers’ penalty area. However, I do think that referees enter games with predispositions regarding whether a player flops and the Arsenal forward has done nothing to dispel an impression that he makes the most of contact. I just wish sometimes he would ride the contact a little more and try to keep things moving.
The sequence that disappointed me the most came after Ødegaard played Havertz in on goal. A lovely slipped past by the captain required a simple first-time finish on the German’s right foot, and he was under no pressure from that side. And yet, he opted to try to cut in on his left foot instead, losing the ball and the massive opportunity. In the meantime, Viktor Gyökeres is rounding into very usable form.
The others
This was a rather delightful weekend of results for the English champions. Spurs, despite initially looking quite coherent at Leeds, were chinned by their hosts and lost 1-0. Chelsea were defeated by the same scoreline at Sunderland. Manchester United hosted Aston Villa and, after going down 0-2 within four minutes, drew level before conceding another two goals and dramatically equalizing again for a final score of 4-4. The result leaves the Red Devils in the relegation zone entering the international break, with a trip to Anfield up next.
However, City’s loss at Forest is the result that I think is most significant, for obvious reasons. Oliver Glasner’s men were due for some positive regression regarding their xG, but a comprehensive 3-1 win against Arsenal’s biggest title rivals was not on my bingo card. Though when you consider the team Enzo Maresca has assembled, maybe it’s not massively surprising.
A theme of this season for City has been an extremely vulnerable defense. Gianluigi Donnarumma seems prone to games where he couldn’t catch a cold, while Marc Guéhi is struggling mightily and there aren’t really any stars in the back four. The most expensive midfield in Premier League history is unbalanced as well, with Elliot Anderson seemingly expected to play the role Declan Rice has for Arsenal while Enzo Fernández (whom Maresca insists on playing after spending a record fee on him) steps on Rayan Cherki’s toes and neither offer much defensively.
Sure, City’s attack boasts a lot of firepower including perhaps the single greatest striker in English top flight history. But while that will bail them out much of the time — like in their 5-3 win over Sunderland — their shoddy defending on the counter will continue to get them into trouble. Forest exploited that to great effect on Saturday, and I think other sides will too.
And for me, that really emphasizes how ludicrous it is that the Gunners are maligned for their defensive solidity. Because clearly, that’s why they’re the best team in England right now. The other sides in the “Big Six” — Spurs, Chelsea, Liverpool, United, and Liverpool — all sport defenses that are far leakier than Arsenal’s. In a league with more parity than ever before, with more talent that will punish mistakes than ever before, that is a design flaw that put you in a hole you can’t dig out of. Watching these teams so far this season, I feel pretty good about the Gunners’ focus on avoiding that problem all together.
Now, the lead is just five points. It is only the beginning of November. A lot can change between now and May. But right now, there is an outright best team in the Premier League. And it’s the one every one keeps calling boring. Maybe there’s a reason for that.
If you enjoyed this piece, please consider following me on Twitter @Shamsdale or on Bluesky @shamsdale.bsky.social.
Subscribe
Or you can buy me a coffee here.