football.london

Havertz VAR error, missed penalty, Michael Oliver nightmare– Arsenal vs Hull referee review

football.london reviews the big decisions by the officials after Arsenal's hard-fought 1-0 win against Hull City

Kai Havertz was at the centre of two big officiating decisions in Arsenal's win over Hull City

Kai Havertz was at the centre of two big officiating decisions in Arsenal's win over Hull City(Image: Shaun Botterill/Getty Images / Premier League)

View 4 Images

Arsenal managed to move six points clear of their main Premier League title rivals Manchester City after the two sides had contrasting results at the weekend. The Gunners secured a one-goal win over Hull City while Enzo Maresca watched his side get comprehensively beaten by Nottingham Forest.

‌

‌

The result saw Brighton move above City to within five points, but the weekend was not without its refereeing controversies once again. The Gunners won in spite of a major refereeing disaster, while Fabian Hurzeler’s side benefitted from a red card, which also has positives for Arsenal in the future.

‌

Michael Oliver has come into focus, and was on VAR for Arsenal’s game with Hull and officiated the Seagulls’ win over Brentford. While Farai Hallam was officiating his first Arsenal game of the season, his second ever after the dead-rubber final day clash against Crystal Palace last season, football.london reviews all the controversies.

Make sure you never miss the latest Arsenal news and opinion by making football.london one of your Google preferred sources

Missed Havertz penalty

No, not that one. This incident preceded the controversial penalty call which everyone has been speaking about and instead involved the same two players. Kai Havertz beat Nobel Mendy to the ball in the box, and as he turned to take it away from him the defender made a clear and significant pull of the German’s shirt.

Havertz went down in the box but the play was waved on by Hallam. The German’s shirt would be tugged similarly later in an offence deemed to be enough for a foul to have been made.

FL review – The problem here is Havertz’s action after the pull, which looks somewhat artificial. The pull itself isn’t enough to bring the German down, but as we saw at Anfield last week, Alexander Isak was encouraged to exaggerate the contact, and him being too nice was what cost him the eye of the official.

FL verdict – Borderline, but if not given on the field, it's unlikely VAR would overturn it, but the same could be said had it been given on the field.

Kai Havertz penalty call against Hull City for Arsenal

Kai Havertz penalty call against Hull City for Arsenal(Image: Premier League)

View 4 Images

Havertz offside penalty fiasco

The one that has grabbed the headlines. In short, Havertz in an offside position is pulled back Isak-Timber-style at Anfield, goes down, and the referee waves play on as the ball moves harmlessly through. VAR asked Hallam to go to the monitor, and he adjudged the defender to have committed a ‘holding offence’, but that Havertz being offside negated the call of a penalty.

FL review – It has been widely shown post-match that the rules dictate that because the holding offence takes place before the offside offence, a penalty should have been given. From a personal point of view, I don’t agree with the rules as they are in this case, and a penalty seems wrong considering Havertz was in an offside position, but these are the rules currently and therefore the officials have made a poor call.

FL verdict – Incorrect decision; a penalty should have been awarded.

Kai Havertz offside VAR decision vs Hull for Arsenal

Kai Havertz offside VAR decision vs Hull for Arsenal(Image: Premier League)

View 4 Images

Michael Oliver controversy continues

Granted, the game in focus here between Brighton and Brentford might leave readers wondering why it features here. However, the Seagulls are currently the closest rivals to Arsenal in the title race, as discussed, while Igor Thiago, who was sent off in this match by Oliver, who was also on VAR at the Emirates on Sunday and part-responsible for the major error, is the official who brandished the red card which will see the Brazilian miss the Bees’ clash with the Gunners through suspension.

FL review – Chema Andres is brushed off initially in a duel by Thiago; the midfielder gets immediately straight back up as the aggressor in the tussle before the striker clearly tries to brush him off again with his arms, but unfortunately the manner in which the arms hit Andres’ chest sends them up into the Brighton player’s face – it doesn’t tick enough boxes for violent conduct and contact with the face being accidental should be considered.

For me, this is another example, sadly, after Phil Foden x Bruno Fernandes and Max Dowman at Fleetwood, where a victim of an aggressive action by an opponent has seen them sent off. It is a theme that needs to be curbed, and it will be interesting if Brentford decide to appeal.

FL verdict - Wrong decision, yellow card.

Igor Thiago sent off for Brentford against Brighton and will miss Arsenal clash

Igor Thiago sent off for Brentford against Brighton and will miss Arsenal clash(Image: Premier League)

View 4 Images

Read full news in source page