hulldailymail.co.uk

Fresh details emerge about Arsenal vs Hull City VAR controversy

City were involved in one of the weekend's big talking points at the Emirates

The VAR decision went Hull City's way at the Emirates

The VAR decision went Hull City's way at the Emirates(Image: Julian Finney/Getty Images)

View Image

Former Premier League referee Demot Gallagher believes referee Farai Hallam and VAR Michael Oliver came to the right ethical decision in Arsenal's 1-0 win over Hull City, even if the law suggests otherwise.

Before the break, City defender Nobel Mendy pulled Kai Havertz's shirt, and the German flopped to the ground inside the penalty area at the Emirates.

After play continued for a period, the referee stopped play to go over and review the incident at the pitchside monitor, before announcing to the crowd that while Mendy had fouled Havertz, the Arsenal striker was in fact offside and therefore a free-kick was awarded to the Tigers.

The law says because Havertz wasn't playing the ball, and the foul occurred before the offside, a penalty should have been awarded. In situations of what's deemed a subjective offside, the on-field referee is called over to the screen to make his own assessment, which is why Hallam did that and then felt it was offside.

Gallagher, who has listened to the matchday audio, revealed Hallam's assistant had initially flagged for offside, so he believes that would have shaped his decision in not giving the spot-kick.

Make sure you never miss the latest Hull City news and opinion by making Hull Live one of your Google preferred sources.

"I think this takes a bit of explaining by the law, because this proves that the law hinders the referee more than anything, because the law actually says that if a player in an offside position is fouled before the offside offence occurs, a foul should be given, so therefore a penalty; that's the law," Gallagher told Sky Sports' Ref Watch programme.

"In law, you should give a penalty. In law, it should be a penalty because it's quite clear the foul occurred before, but when you think about this, and we talk about common sense, and we talk about football as it is, and handball being a classic example, cos none of us agree that some of the goals should be disallowed, but they have to be.

"If you look at this, Havertz's one hundred per cent is in an offside position. His starting position is offside. There's three things he can't do. He can't play the ball cause he'll be interfering with play. He can't challenge an opponent cause he'll be interfering with the opponent, and he can't go in front of the goalkeeper. So what can he do? He can't do anything. He's in an offside position. And the net result should be a penalty. How is that acceptable?

"What I'm saying is this is where common sense is not allowed, isn't it, because what I've just explained to you is when you think of it morally and ethically. Can you really give a penalty for a player who is never, ever in an onside position?

"He can't play the ball, he can't challenge an opponent, he can't stand in front of the goalkeeper, so what can he do apart from stand on the field? The letter of the law says penalty. The ethical part of me says, how can you give a penalty for that?

"What I will say, very, very interesting. The process of the VAR was fantastic because I've actually heard the audio of this, and the assistant calls offside the minute the ball comes in. I think the starting position for the assistant was always offside, which is interesting. And then you go, well, that should be overruled by that, that should be overruled by that, but I think the process was great how they came to it."

Former Gunners striker Jay Bothroyd then asked if Mendy's tug of the shirt warranted the German to fall to the floor and seek a penalty.

"Do you think that Havertz's challenge is a penalty on the tug of the shirt?" he questioned, before Gallagher responded by suggesting Mendy needs to be more careful, having got away with one last weekend against Ipswich Town.

"Well, he (Mendy) shouldn't do it," Gallagher continued. "This is back to the Isak (shirt pull in the Liverpool vs Arsenal game) last week, isn't it? He's (Mendy) the wrong side. Interesting about this player (Mendy): the week before, he got the wrong side against Dara O'Shea, didn't he? He ripped the shirt off his back and got away with it. Two weeks running, he's got lucky, same player. He's on the wrong side of Havertz.

"All my instincts when I played football was that he's the wrong side. If I was a forward. The defender panicked, so he grabbed the shirt. They came to a decision which I think ethically is right, yeah, but in law is wrong. He (referee) would have known in his ear that the assistant had already said Havertz is offside, and he did flag offside."

Tigers boss Sergej Jakirovic admitted Mendy was lucky to escape that decision, but was left furious with Christos Tzolis' foul on Mohamed-Ali Cho, which would have seen the Greek international sent off for being the last man. That incident was not covered.

Here at Hull Live , we are dedicated to bringing you the best Hull City coverage and analysis. Make sure you don't miss out on the latest City news by joining our free WhatsApp group.

You can get all the breaking news and best analysis sent straight to your phone by clicking here to subscribe. You can also subscribe to our free newsletter service. Click here to be sent all the day's biggest stories.

[Hull Daily Mail Icon

GET MORE FROM US

Choose Hull Live as a 'Preferred Source' on Google News for quick access to the news you value.

Google Preferred Source Badge](https://www.google.com/preferences/source?q=hulldailymail.co.uk)

Google Preferred Source Badge

Read full news in source page