The Colts might be regretting their rejection of the Giants’ offer of second- and fifth-round picks for running back Jonathan Taylor. Indianapolis would “strongly consider” a similar package if it were put back on the table, according to NFL insider Jordan Schultz.
The Colts’ change of mind could be a signal that Taylor is interested in playing for a new team. He has not submitted a formal trade request, but said after Sunday’s loss to the Cowboys that he is unsure of his future. As the prospect of a move has become more real with specific teams involved, he may now embrace such a move, per Schultz.
“My understanding is that he’s open to be traded,” Schultz said. “In fact, I think he’d welcome a fresh start at this point.”
But unless Taylor actively pushes for an exit, the Colts seem content to keep the three-time Pro Bowler in the fold. He was just signed to a two-year, $44MM extension that runs through 2028, his age-29 season. He has shown signs of slowing down this season, but that can also be attributed to Indianapolis’ changes along their offensive line.
“The Colt’s don’t want to force a trade,” Schultz adds, noting that the team could revisit a Taylor trade in the offseason. However, with more options available, teams may not be as desperate for a running back upgrade. As a result, the Giants’ offer might be the best the Colts can get, now or in the future.
Multiple reports have indicated that the Giants could re-engage in trade talks. But with the Colts backtracking their initial rejection under an interim general manager, New York could smell blood in the water and pull the additional Day 3 pick from their proposed package for Taylor. Unless the Colts have a competing offer, they may need to jump at the Giants’ last, best offer – if they even come back to the table.