Manchester City have a midfield issue and Enzo Maresca faces a selection dilemma when the Premier League returns
Manchester City pair Enzo Fernandez and Ayyoub Bouaddi
Manchester City boss Enzo Maresca could face a midfield choice between Enzo Fernandez and Ayyoub Bouaddi
View 2 Images
Enzo Fernandez signed as Enzo Maresca's guy. Manchester City smashed their transfer record, just weeks after breaking it to sign Elliot Anderson, to bring Fernandez in from Chelsea.
Maresca knew him from his time at Stamford Bridge and felt the Argentina international would help others adapt to Maresca's methods. The City boss trusts Fernandez and believes he can be a key player in leading the new look era at the Etihad.
Speaking after the £125million deal was confirmed in September, Maresca said: "I know what he can bring to the team. He's a winner, has a winner's mentality. He knows how to win - World Cup, Club World Cup. The main thing is that, again, he's a winner."
Except in these last few weeks, City haven't been winning. They have lost three straight Premier League games to fall six points behind Arsenal, and there are concerns around the midfield makeup and how easily City are conceding goals.
Maresca is utilising Anderson as a lone pivot with Rayan Cherki as an advanced 10 and Fernandez slightly wider on the right. The Etihad chief wants to get his wingers isolated against opposition full-backs and places emphasis on bravery, pressing man-to-man, showing courage, and winning the ball back quickly. There is a nod to PSG and their approach under Luis Enrique which has seen the French side win the past two Champions League titles.
The meeting between the sides in Manchester earlier this season was perhaps the microcosm of Maresca's City. Their shortcomings were on show in a first half when PSG ran riot, thanks in part to their own quality but also to the space City afforded them while performing their own high-wire act. Yet in the second half, City responded with such courage and threat that there was a belief the Blues were going to mount a sensational comeback before Maghnes Akliouche's shot spun away from Gianluigi Donnarumma and in.
That second 45 minutes is particularly pertinent just now given the midfield debate. Ayyoub Bouaddi came on at the break and produced an accomplished display against the best team in Europe, helping set City up for their improved showing.
The 19-year-old had also impressed in the Champions League win at Porto, when he started in place of Anderson, but has found minutes harder to come by in the Premier League. He's made only two top-flight starts, completing 90 minutes just once, but has shown - both in his European performances for City and his international and club appearances prior to moving to Manchester - that he offers the insurance City are crying out for in midfield.
Fernandez, who is out of form, is the obvious fall guy given Anderson has been City's best midfielder and Rayan Cherki is able to turn games in the blink of an eye.
But that means Maresca dropping a club-record signing and a player in whom he has placed a huge amount of trust and faith.
It would be a big call for the boss and perhaps expecting Bouaddi to be an instant fix to all City's troubles is misguided. But the defeat at Forest should serve as a wake-up call that a change is required. The space Forest were able to exploit was frightening and left a fragile defence too easily exposed.
The average position for Manchester City's players at Nottingham Forest highlights just how far Enzo Fernandez (17) is away from Elliot Anderson (5)
The average position for Manchester City's players at Nottingham Forest highlights just how far Enzo Fernandez (17) is away from Elliot Anderson (5)
View 2 Images
"There is defensive howler after defensive howler and it's at the point where it can't just be on the players, it has to be something to do with the way they are set up that it is asking too much of people for error after error to be made every single game," said the MEN's Chief City writer Simon Bajkowski on this week's Talking City podcast.
"They have conceded 17 in the last eight games and Maresca used the phrase silly goals at Leipzig. I think 12 or 13 of those 17 have been individual errors, glaringly bad.
"There has been a lot of arm waving and pointing and shouting at each other in the last few games and it feels like the players can't get to grips with what they are being asked to do and it feels like the midfield are far too open.
"The obvious elephant in the room is Ayyoub Bouaddi. Everyone remembers his performance against PSG in the second half and thinks he is the obvious answer.
"At the minute, Anderson is a six and is not being able to do everything he is asked to do. Cherki is playing as a 10 well in front of him and Fernandez is playing as a seven almost, to the right side of the midfield, and no-one is helping Anderson. There is no strength or solidity in midfield.
"There is enough that has gone wrong in the midfield to put Bouaddi in and see how it looks."