Manchester City manager Enzo Maresca has had a similar start to Pep Guardiola ten years ago but there is one key difference
Guardiola
Pep Guardiola(Image: Michael Regan/Getty Images)
View Image
Enzo Maresca knew when he took the Manchester City job that he would be compared to Pep Guardiola. He also knew, as anyone who has lived on Earth for the last 10 years would, that it will be very difficult to come out on top in those scenarios given the staggering success at the Etihad over the last decade.
"It’s something that I know – after 10 games, if we’ve got 10 points, 20 points, 30 points. People will be comparing it to Pep after 10 games," he told reporters in Seoul this summer. "But it’s something – it is what it is. It doesn’t put pressure on me.
"I’ve said many times while I was at Leicester or Chelsea, he’s the best manager in the world over he last 15 or 20 years. When he started in Spain, everyone wanted to play like Barcelona, he moved to Germany everyone wanted to play like Bayern, he comes to England and everyone wants to play like City. Someone asked me if it’s the impossible job to follow him – maybe but at the same time it’s a privilege."
What is striking from the starts of both managers at City is how similar they are. Guardiola won his opening six league games, went winless in his next three, and then won their tenth game; Maresca won his first seven before losing his next three so has accrued two fewer points.
It has been the same trajectory, with a perfect start that offered much but hid cracks in the performances that then quickly became exposed. From big derby wins to worrying collapses away from home, there have been highs and lows amid questions over whether this football can win the Premier League.
In that sense, all is not as gloomy for Maresca as it felt when they were being picked off at the City Ground last weekend. The Italian is only months into his tenure and nothing is so wrong that it cannot be fixed.
However, the big difference is in recruitment. It isn't that Guardiola didn't spend in his first year but most of that time was working out who was and wasn't capable of being part of the project.
It was the 2017 summer transfer window that was revolutionary for the team, with a large chunk of the squad offloaded and key players such as Bernardo Silva, Ederson, and Kyle Walker brought in. That immediate upgrade was enough to transform City into one of the best sides ever seen in English football.
Maresca's problem is that City have already had their version of that transfer window. Nearly all of the players signed in the last two years that were no longer seen as part of the future - Omar Marmoush, Nico Gonzalez, Tijjani Reijnders et al - have gone and their sales used to fund a mammoth spend on signings who are expected to be the bedrock of Maresca's City.
Make sure you never miss the latest Manchester City news and opinion by making Manchester Evening News one of your Google preferred sources.
From record buys Elliot Anderson and Enzo Fernandez to Iliman Ndiaye and Ayyoub Bouaddi, the 2026 transfer window has been City's attempt to replicate what they did in 2017. Even if their 115 appeal is successful, it is incredibly unlikely that they can turn around next summer and rip up their squad again if it isn't working.
That means Maresca has to make things work with what he has got, using this week to find solutions with his current players rather than thinking of extra signings that could make things easier. There are plenty of signs from the opening few months that he can, and City would not have hired him if they did not think he could, but right now the biggest contrast to Guardiola is that Maresca does not have future recruitment to use as a trump card for his system.