Arsenal benefited from a significant refereeing error during their 1-0 victory over Liverpool at Anfield, according to the Premier League’s independent Key Match Incidents (KMI) Panel.
The panel has concluded that Liverpool should have been awarded a penalty for Jurrien Timber’s challenge on Alexander Isak in the 20th minute of the encounter on November 1.
Timber was accused of holding the Liverpool striker inside the penalty area, but the referee allowed play to continue and the video assistant referee did not intervene.
Following its review, the five-member panel voted 4-1 that the challenge constituted a foul and should have resulted in a penalty.
Three members also believed VAR should have recommended an on-field review because the decision represented a clear and obvious error.
The remaining two considered the impact of Timber’s holding sufficiently subjective that the incident did not meet the threshold for intervention.
According to the Premier League’s published findings, the majority felt that Timber’s actions prevented Isak from progressing towards goal.
However, the panel unanimously rejected suggestions that the Arsenal defender should have been dismissed for denying an obvious goalscoring opportunity.
The findings represent a notable development following Arsenal’s narrow victory, which strengthened their position at the top of the Premier League.
The Gunners secured all three points through a solitary goal, extending their impressive start to the defence of their league title.
Nevertheless, the review suggests Liverpool were denied an opportunity to change the course of the contest from the penalty spot.
The panel also examined several other incidents involving Arsenal players, although it supported the officials’ decisions in each case.
Timber was cleared over a separate challenge on Alexis Mac Allister in the 29th minute, with all five members agreeing that no penalty was warranted.
A subsequent appeal involving Christos Tzolis and Cody Gakpo was also dismissed, as the contact was considered insufficient to constitute a foul.
Liverpool’s appeal for handball against Timber was rejected because the ball struck his supporting arm.
Meanwhile, the panel unanimously supported the decision not to dismiss Noni Madueke following an incident involving Mac Allister in the 79th minute.
It concluded that the contact was negligible and the Liverpool midfielder’s reaction was exaggerated.
Across the ninth round of Premier League fixtures, the panel deemed 76 per cent of referees’ on-field decisions correct.
All seven VAR overturns during the round were also considered justified.
While the findings will not affect the result, they confirm that Arsenal escaped punishment for a challenge the panel believes should have given Liverpool a penalty.