Crystal Palace v Arsenal FC - Premier League
Photo by Harriet Lander/Copa/Getty Images
Arsenal are top of the Premier League, five points clear after winning nine of their first 10 games, and third in the Champions League table. But it hasn’t stopped the criticism.
Six of their nine league wins have come by a single goal, and the narrow 1-0 win over Hull before the break only added to the noise. Plenty of people, mostly outside the club, think Mikel Arteta’s champions are too controlled and not entertaining enough.
One well-respected former manager isn’t having it, though.
Roy Hodgson defends Mikel Arteta’s Arsenal
Speaking to Jeff Stelling on OLBG, Roy Hodgson was asked about the claims that Arsenal are too pragmatic.
“Well, he’s done a fantastic job. There’s no doubt about that,” Hodgson said. “And I think those criticisms are always a bit harsh because, you know, we all accept that the only way you can be regarded as successful and really keep your fans happy is to win games.
“So when you’re winning games all the time, you’re going to Nottingham Forest… you know it’s going to be a competitive encounter. You eventually get a 1-0 win. I think you’ve just got to be satisfied and happy with that.
“And I don’t agree either that there’s anything wrong at all with their football. They play some very good football with some outstanding individual players and some lovely moves.”
Arsenal fans have their say on the ‘boring’ debate
We asked fans on Talking Points whether Arteta is getting enough credit, and the debate was lively. Plenty agreed with Hodgson.
Don’t think Arsenal fans are the ones complaining tbh. As for the rest, what else have they got? We’re not soft anymore, not leaky at the back, not getting battered anymore. Boring football is the last stick left to beat us with. Let them enjoy it while it lasts!
Arsenal aren’t soft any more, they aren’t leaky at the back, and they don’t get bullied. For some, the style of play is the last thing left to criticise.
I think it’s harsh. After the invincible team, Arsenal were criticised for playing lovely football and not winning the league. Now, after the winning the league, it’s not pretty enough. It’s possible to have both – but for the sake of debate, I’d like to ask Arsenal fans would they sacrifice being genuine title contenders for sexy football?
That’s the irony. For years, Arsenal were mocked for playing pretty football and winning nothing. Now they’re winning, and they’re not pretty enough.
Not everyone was convinced, though. One user felt that with the league as it is, Arsenal should be taking more risks.
Fans are right to expect more. The quality of the league is so poor this year, why not take risks and play some football? If Brighton are your biggest rivals you don’t need to be holding onto 1-0 wins against Hull
Ultimately, Arsenal fans don’t particularly care about style if it delivers results and, more importantly, silverware. Arteta’s side are the class of the league: the deepest, most complete team, and one that knows exactly what it is. Whether they can blow teams away is a perfectly valid discussion, but that’s about it.
If anything, the more boring Arsenal are for neutrals, the better. Jeopardy creates excitement, and if you want to win the league, jeopardy is exactly what you need to restrict. Pep Guardiola’s best City sides were a tough watch at times too, perhaps in a different way, but that was none of their concern.
It’s also not really a “style” Arteta will die for. It’s the style that suits his players. When you have Gabriel, William Saliba and Declan Rice, you’re naturally going to lean on being strong out of possession and dangerous from corners. Arsenal will play the way that wins, and right now, that’s working perfectly well.