Manchester City have had a mixed start to life under Enzo Maresca, with a perfect beginning way giving way to worries in recent weeks
Manchester City winners and losers under Enzo Maresca
Manchester City winners and losers under Enzo Maresca
View Image
Manchester City have begun a new chapter in their history over the last few months. Enzo Maresca has replaced Pep Guardiola after 10 years with the Catalan as manager and the squad has been transformed over an extraordinary summer of business in the transfer window.
Some of the longest serving players, such as Bernardo Silva, Rodri, John Stones and Nathan Ake, have left and there is a new feeling around the club with Maresca now in the hotseat. While the former Chelsea coach was picked because he shares many of the same qualities as Guardiola, he is also intent on doing things his own way.
That change has been good for some players in the squad, who have benefitted from the way Maresca wants to do things and have been significant contributors to a start on the pitch. At the same time, it hasn't been great for everybody so far with a few players not currently getting the opportunities that they would like and others struggling as the team form has taken a dip.
Here is a look at the winners and losers so far from Maresca's first few months at City.
Erling Haaland
Let's start with the obvious. Statistically, Erling Haaland had his worst start to a Premier League season. His five goals from the opening five games were fewer than he managed in 2022 (nine goals), 2023 (seven), 2024 (ten) and 2025 (six).
However, his goals were crucial to winning City points with three of his five being the first goal in the match that has given his team the control they need. It had been a frustrating afternoon for him at Old Trafford before his superbly-taken effort was rather forgotten about in the controversy surrounding that matchwinner, and he also put the Sunderland game to bed finally.
Most importantly, Haaland has continued to score. There haven't been the eye-catching hat-tricks but it has been a steady return of goals that have kept City ticking - including the late finish against RB Leipzig. To say Haaland himself was worried about his physical and mental state after such a long year that only ended at the quarter-finals of the World Cup, everything appears to be fine and there are also signs, particularly with his heading, that he is still improving.
Maresca is setting up the team to maximise goal opportunities for Haaland, and the big Norwegian looks to be in the frame of mind to have another big season.
Rayan Ait-Nouri
Ait-Nouri was hoping for a fresh start after struggling to get minutes under Guardiola, but things have not looked great in the opening months. He was overlooked at full-back as teenager Kaden Braithwaite came on at Crystal Palace and then Abdukodir Khusanov was preferred to replace Josko Gvardiol at left-back for the second half against Porto.
Ait-Nouri did come on in that game in front of Khusanov, and afterwards Maresca said that he saw the player more as a winger than a full-back. Competition for that position is already tough though, and the return of Jeremy Doku and Nico O'Reilly from respective injuries add even more on the left side of the pitch. Add in a failed deadline day approach involving a potential move to United and it has not been the start of the season that Ait-Nouri wanted.
After more time out of the team, Maresca said that Ait-Nouri was competing with full-backs and after 10 Premier League games the defender has not played a single minute in the competition and has been left out of multiple squads. A January exit looks needed for all parties.
Elliot Anderson
If the jury remains out on some players, Anderson has quickly justified one of the biggest price tags in the game. City thought that £116million was a fair price for somebody who was one of the best midfielders in the Premier League last year and also starred at the World Cup, and they have been shown to be right.
Anderson is still learning in the game and also getting to grips with what is being asked of him by Maresca, so he is not the finished article. He is already exciting and impressing supporters with his performances though and there is a level of quality and consistency to his game that makes him an automatic pick in the City team.
Gianluigi Donnarumma
Inside the club his position remains stronger than it was last season, with Geronimo Rulli not yet having the same clamour to step in as James Trafford did among the fanbase. Donnarumma has become one of the captains, the coaches have taken steps to minimise risk when he has the ball at his feet, and he has made some important saves.
At the same time, the goalkeeper has not helped himself with careless errors in a string of games that have caught up with him in recent weeks as they have cost the team. Having enjoyed a strong start to the season where he became a safer option, Donnarumma is now under scrutiny again and that places more spotlight on Maresca and his decision-making.
It still feels like the manager is a long way from switching up his goalkeepers, yet the only reason there is a question around it is because of Donnarumma's unforced errors.
Floyd Samba
The early hype around City's academy this season was with Ryan McAidoo, who wowed with just a half of football in Hong Kong and had Maresca purring over him as the sort of winger that he loves. He has gone on to have the most opportunities in the first team, yet Floyd Samba has made more headlines.
The 17-year-old got two goals in a sensational debut at home to Norwich in the Carabao Cup, cheered on by his family as he played out of position as a No.9 but came up with the goods. He has since started against Brighton in the cup, and also the Champions League game at home to AEK Athens.
Make sure you never miss the latest Manchester City news and opinion by making Manchester Evening News one of your Google preferred sources.
Samba is still at the very beginning of his career and will hope for some minutes in his preferred position as the season goes on, but he has quickly won Maresca's trust to have been backed already in some important games playing out of position.
Enzo Fernandez
A winner in the sense that he has quickly nailed down a spot in the XI and is one of the first names on the teamsheet since his record £125m move. The players like him, sponsors love him, and he already has his own chant with the fanbase. However, as the team performances have dropped his presence in it and his contributions have come into the firing line more than anyone else.
Fernandez hasn't offered enough to stop strong criticism from a section of supporters, and even fans with more mild opinions are not wild about what he has been showing for the team. The situation is heightened because, rightly or wrongly, many think Ayyoub Bouaddi deserves more opportunities and see his path blocked when Fernandez is in the team.
If Fernandez wants to be recognised as a winner by more of the fanbase, he needs to start doing more to make City pick up victories on the pitch.
[Manchester Evening News Icon
GET MORE FROM US
Choose Manchester Evening News as a 'Preferred Source' on Google News for quick access to the news you value.
Google Preferred Source Badge](https://www.google.com/preferences/source?q=manchestereveningnews.co.uk)
Google Preferred Source Badge