I remember when Arsenal first signed Noni Madueke. Of course, it was just a year and change ago, so I don’t say this as if it is some impressive feat of recollection. However, I doubt that moment in time will be any less striking a decade from now than it remains now.
I don’t know what it was about the English winger that prompted such a vitriolic response from Arsenal fans. Perhaps it was sheerly just the fact that it was another player the Gunners acquired from Chelsea. Some among the club faithful resent the idea of giving large sums of money (in this case, £48.5 million plus £3.5 million in add-ons) to what has historically been a bitter rival of the current English champions. And he joined a somewhat long line of arrivals from that side of London who aren’t unquestionable — David Luiz, Willian, Jorginho, Kai Havertz, Raheem Sterling, and Kepa Arrizabalaga before him during the Mikel Arteta era alone doesn’t exactly make for a flawless track record. Add William Gallas and Petr Čech to that list and concern is surely understandable.
Maybe it was Madueke’s public image of being immature and problematic, as unfounded as that proved to be in hindsight. Unfortunately, many saw the durag he wears during games and the somewhat nonchalant attitude he occasionally carries himself with and made their assumptions. His argument with Cole Palmer over who got to take Chelsea’s second penalty against Everton in 2024 didn’t help perceptions.
Or the animus toward him might simply be because his arrival interrupted the career arc certain Arsenal supporters had planned out for the club’s academy products. Even now, people will tell you that Ethan Nwaneri should be Bukayo Saka’s understudy at right wing (even though the man now on loan at Borussia Dortmund is simply not a wide player at this point). Others believed that Max Dowman should have been the direct backup to Saka instead of spending significant money on someone else to fill that role.
In any event, I’m not sure I’ve seen anything like the tidal wave of malice toward a new signing like I saw with Madueke. For any of these reasons above or others I can’t imagine, the official announcement of the Englishman’s arrival was met with pleas for him not to sign his contract, as well as death threats. A mural of the winger near the Emirates Stadium was defaced before he had even played his first match in red and white. The dark underbelly of this fan base appallingly revealed itself to a player who was genuinely excited about joining The Arsenal.
I won’t lie, I myself was surprised initially by the links to Madueke. They felt lazy, almost as if a journalist had put two and two together and come up with “of course Arsenal would want a right winger from Chelsea.” But then the more reliable sources began reporting on the purported move. David Ornstein of The Athletic revealed that the Gunners had agreed personal terms with the Englishman early in July of 2025. Five days later, Ornstein reported that Arsenal were on the cusp of agreeing a deal with Chelsea.
In hindsight, it was fairly easy to get onboard with the move if you thought about it objectively. He was a Premier League-proven winger with exposure to some of the highest levels of football. He could play on both flanks effectively. At just over £50 million, his transfer fee was honestly rather shrewd compared to the prices that comparable players were and still are going for. The same age as Bukayo Saka, Madueke could be a reliable time-sharer with an Arsenal talisman who had begun to show signs of wear and tear. And the data experts saw in him a player who could explode into an elite attacker if he put things together in his game.
I think we’re currently watching that explosion unfold.
In his first season in north London, and even at the beginning of the current campaign, Madueke exuded rawness in his play. Blessed with top-end pace, elite athleticism, and an imposing six-foot build, the Englishman could naturally be a handful for almost any defender. However, his actions in the final third were inconsistent at best and downright erratic much of the time. He exhibited poor decision-making, dribbling needlessly into traffic or trying too hard to cut in on his left foot and shoot when it simply wasn’t viable. His technical quality left much to be desired as well — on a semi-regular basis Madueke dribbled out of bounds and wildly hacked at crosses or shots.
But on occasion, the winger unleashed moments of tremendous ability during this time as well. The thunderbolt from long range after dribbling past a few Club Brugge players is perhaps the most famous example. There was additionally a winning goal against Bayern Munich and the Olimpico he scored at Elland Road. I also remember a clever flick that allowed Ben White to assist the opener against Brentford at the Emirates Stadium and the header he won to score in the reverse fixture. Ultimately, however, these flashes of quality were too infrequent for the Englishman to really establish himself as a key piece in the squad. During a title-winning season in which Saka missed significant time, Madueke still always felt firmly part of the B team.
Since the first international break of the current season, though — and particularly since stepping in for the injured Saka at Bayern a few weeks ago — Madueke appears to have progressed in his game by leaps and bounds. Perhaps being left out of the England squad by Thomas Tuchel ignited a fire in the Arsenal forward. Perhaps after over a year of development under Arteta, a winger whisperer whom Raheem Sterling and Leroy Sané credit for their evolutions into world class wide men, things are finally clicking for Madueke. Perhaps it’s both.