The substitutes’ board went up after 11 minutes. All of the Chelsea players’ heads swivelled to the sidelines, where Veerle Buurman stood waiting. No one moved. Katie McCabe’s eyes burned across as if to say: “This better not be me.” It was not McCabe coming off; it was Kadeisha Buchanan. As she walked over, she refused to make eye contact with her manager, who tried to say something to her. Buchanan marched straight down the tunnel.
This was Sonia Bompastor pulling the emergency “Plan B for Bunny” lever. Everyone at Stamford Bridge could see that Buchanan had failed to get to grips with Bunny Shaw, the WSL’s top scorer, who had 14 goals in 13 games across all competitions this season prior to this match. Bompastor decided that she was not going to waste time finding out if Buchanan could grow into the contest.
The official line was that Buchanan had taken a knock to her head in Friday’s training session, with Bompastor saying that she felt like she was “not herself”. “I took the responsibility for the substitution because I know my player and she was not right,” she said.
Buurman admitted to the BBC post-match that she “didn’t expect” to come on so early, but it was a decision that paid off in spades. The 20-year-old was named the league’s Rising Star last season, and she double-teamed [with Lucy Bronze, 15 years her senior](https://observer.co.uk/news/sport/article/sunderland-have-california-cash-now-for-el-lassico), to keep Shaw quiet. She was lavishly and deservedly congratulated by her team-mates at full-time, as well as by members of Chelsea’s executive team.
The defender was not the only change that Bompastor made before a ball had even been kicked in the second half. Sandy Baltimore put Chelsea ahead four minutes into injury time at the end of the first half – rifling the ball in with her left foot – but there was no opportunity for her after the break, with Maika Hamano on in her place. Again, Bompastor said this was a decision that was not tactical per se, but one she was forced to make due to the minutes her players were able to play and the substitute windows available to her.
#### ‘I took responsibility for the substitution because I know my player and she was not right’
### ‘I took responsibility for the substitution because I know my player and she was not right’
Sonia Bompastor on Kadeisha Buchanan
Chelsea managers have never been afraid to make early changes. [The watching Emma Hayes](https://observer.co.uk/news/sport/article/bay-fcs-paul-green-emma-hayes-told-me-this-was-the-perfect-role), sitting between Sarina Wiegman and Ian Wright, must have reflected fondly seeing her legacy continued. She once famously took off Lauren James and Sophie Ingle 36 minutes into a game against Manchester City with her team 2-0 down. But this was more proactive still from Bompastor, who has made half-time changes in multiple games this season, including against Crystal Palace and Roma.
Bompastor pushed back on the idea that this was suggestive of a poorly prepared gameplan. “It happens in football,” she said. “As much as you have everything ready for the game, it happens. Sometimes things are not going the way you want and you need to react. I’m used to it.”
Manchester City looked like they were going to turn the screw in the second half until Ayaka Yamashita rushed out towards the ball, only to find the onrushing Alyssa Thompson. The City goalkeeper was sent off, and despite a frenetic finish, it was always an uphill battle thereafter.
Neither team will have felt, ahead of the game, that losing would put an end to their WSL title hopes, but Chelsea are now one point ahead of City. Their biggest boost will have come from the fact that they have now taken nine points in three games from their top-four rivals, compared to eight points in the entirety of last season. It reflects a mentality reset that Chelsea have focused on this term.
A case in point when analysing how much they struggled last season was their FA Cup semi-final against City at Stamford Bridge. They were 2-0 up in that game with 85 minutes gone, then collapsed to lose 3-2. City went on to make it a league and cup double, having inflicted another humiliating defeat on Chelsea after beating them 5-1 earlier in the campaign.
How they would cope as a team then, after a tough week in which they had drawn unexpectedly against Everton last Saturday and BK Häcken in the Champions League, was a big test of the work that had been done so far this season.
“In terms of last season, I was really convinced about what we needed to change coming into this season,” said Bompastor late last month.
“I always reflect a lot when things are going wrong, but also when they are positive. I was convinced about what we had to do differently. The team being more together this season helps a lot in terms of having better performances on the pitch. You can have a really good team, really good players, but if they don’t want to work for each other, it’s impossible to achieve your goals and your ambition.”
The arrival of players like Katie McCabe, who told the squad prior to kick-off that they needed to play like dogs, has been a key part of that rejuvenation. “We’re in a better place than where we were last year,” admitted Keira Walsh after the win.
Despite concerns over Chelsea’s profligacy in front of goal – they once again squandered a number of big chances in this game – their improved ability as a unit has been obvious. There will be more twists and turns in the title race from here, but the win over City was important, as much to draw a line under last season as it was to push on in this one.
Photograph by Harriet Lander/Chelsea FC via Getty Images