sportingnews.com

Would Pep Guardiola really coach the USMNT? Why former Man City boss would be a slam dunk hire for U.S. Soccer

Would Pep Guardiola really coach the USMNT? Why former Man City boss would be a slam dunk hire for U.S. Soccer image

Back in the fall of 2024, hiring Mauricio Pochettino as USMNT head coach was considered a massive coup for the U.S. Soccer federation.

In the wake of Gregg Berhalter's departure after a disastrous Copa America on home soil, securing the services of a man who had previously managed PSG, Chelsea, and Tottenham was a massive moment in USMNT history.

Just over two years later, the federation is back in the same situation, as Pochettino's departure for Manchester United again leaves a vacancy at the helm of the men's national team.

The federation, of course, will have a list of candidates to fill that position, but it starts with one very clear and obvious favorite. While some may try to downplay U.S. Soccer's ability to secure a top name like Pep Guardiola, or his fit for the program, there's absolutely no doubt that securing his signature would be a slam dunk for the USMNT.

MORE: Why Mauricio Pochettino was a smashing success as USMNT head coach

Latest news, reports for Pep Guardiola to USMNT

Even before Mauricio Pochettino confirmed his departure from U.S. Soccer, The Athletic reported that Pep Guardiola was the "top target" for the federation to replace their outgoing Argentine head coach.

Then, on November 14 just hours before the USMNT was slated to play the first leg of their CONCACAF Nations League quarterfinal against Haiti, Ben Jacobs and Robert Calcutt of TalkSport reported that U.S. Soccer was set for "initial negotiations" with Guardiola about taking over the national team.

This meeting was only for early "exploratory talks" and "not advanced," but crucially, the report claimed that Guardiola is "open to the role" of taking over the USMNT.

International football is clearly on Guardiola's radar. He was courted by the Italian federation back in the summer, but turned down the opportunity, as it came just weeks after he had departed Man City and wanted a rest. "Pep was honest," said Italian Football Federation (FIGC) president Giovanni Malago at the time. "He took a sabbatical, partly for family reasons, but if he’d done anything, he would have done it with us."

There is clearly a long way to go for U.S. Soccer to convince Guardiola to become the next USMNT head coach. Guardiola may feel he is above U.S. Soccer, and he may be committed to taking a full year off from management. But if he were not interested in the role, he would have turned it down immediately. The chances of him being named as Pochettino's are not zero.

FARRELL: Why Pep Guardiola to the USMNT is not a pipe dream

Why Pep Guardiola to USMNT would be a slam dunk hire

It seems to be stating the obvious that the greatest club coach of our generation would be the right man for the job to lead the USMNT, but there still appear to be some dissenters who wish to galaxy brain their way out of what would be the greatest coaching coup in recent memory.

Former U.S. stars Landon Donovan and Tim Howard tried to claim on their podcast Unfiltered Soccer that hiring Guardiola "would not be right" for the USMNT.

"He's absolutely not the right manager for this team for the length of time that it's going to take to get through the next World Cup," said Howard. "Pep Guardiola has only ever succeeded with Tier 1 players.

"We have probably Tier 3 players," Howard continued. "Barcelona, Bayern Munich, and Manchester City with more money than god. We — me, you, and every other football fan in the world — we actually don't know if Pep Guardiola is a good manager coaching level 2 or 3 players, we do not know, and nobody out there can tell me they know."

This is, of course, a nonsense argument. By the letter of the law, Howard is right, we don't know. But do we think U.S. Soccer can afford to postulate that Guardiola — the greatest manager of our generation, one who has been historically innovative from a tactical standpoint — is not smart enough to manage players of the level on the USMNT?

That is, of course, absurd. Sure, maybe Guardiola wouldn't be able to win a World Cup, or a hypothetical Champions League title, with the players in the USMNT squad, but should that stop them from hiring him? Of course not.

Guardiola is a tactical genius, no matter what level of players he is coaching. Would his system be complicated for the USMNT players to learn? Absolutely, but they managed to grasp Mauricio Pochettino's relatively complicated 4-2-3-1 pressing system pretty quickly, so with three years in charge, Guardiola would absolutely be capable of adjusting his setup to fit the player pool and its talent profile.

Pochettino's tearful goodbye to the U.S. federation probably helps as well. It took the Argentine's dream job to lure him out of his contract early, and he was clearly emotional in his departure. The relationships he crafted and the project he was building were clearly close to his heart, and that should be a signal to other top managers like Guardiola that they have the opportunity to create something special in the United States.

Pep Guardiola is the greatest club manager of our generation. Securing his commitment would not only elevate the United States higher than ever before, but would present a coup of epic proportions. This is an exciting time for fans of U.S. Soccer.

Read full news in source page