Arsenal sporting director Andrea Berta is facing a massive January transfer window tasked with delivering what Mikel Arteta needs to take his side to the ultimate level
Andrea Berta is coming under the spotlight at Arsenal ahead of the January transfer window
Andrea Berta is coming under the spotlight at Arsenal ahead of the January transfer window(Image: David Price/Arsenal FC via Getty Images)
View 3 Images
Andrea Berta, the Arsenal sporting director, is facing a key moment in his career in North London. The Italian’s stock has risen and fallen over the past 18 months across three transfer windows of varying levels of impact and success.
No doubt, following the summer of 2025, Berta was initially labelled a hero for the signings that he made. The club added eight new players to the group that would eventually go on to become Premier League champions.
With Manchester City signing Antoine Semenyo and Marc Guehi in January, the Gunners remained unmoved. Locked out by financial restrictions, they were unable, like their title rivals, to strengthen.
Make sure you never miss the latest Arsenal news and opinion by making football.london one of your Google preferred sources.
The club waited until the summer, therefore, to move, and having become champions, many expected more. Especially after losing the Champions League final, Mikel Arteta had said that his expectations were that the club needed to move: “Very, very ambitious, very fast and very smart."
football.london quizzed Arteta when the window closed in September whether those tick boxes had been checked, to which he said unequivocally: “Yeah, 100% ticked. The outcome after can be different to what you expect, but the intention is certainly there, which is, in my opinion, what I value the most."
But what is interesting about Arteta’s answer is that the outcome of the window was clearly different to his hopes. While the club may, in his view, have moved fast and smart and with ambition, what happened was perhaps not exactly what he had in his mind’s eye come the start of September and the window’s close.
Arsenal had allowed Gabriel Jesus, Gabriel Martinelli and Leandro Trossard to leave, bringing in nearly £90million for the club; Ethan Nwaneri also left on loan, but only Christos Tzolis, a relatively unknown player thought not to be a starter for Arsenal but more a depth option to the marquee forward everyone was expecting.
Arsenal sporting director Andrea Berta with Bruno Guimaraes
Arsenal sporting director Andrea Berta with Bruno Guimaraes (Image: David Price/Arsenal FC via Getty Images)
View 3 Images
But after missing out on Morgan Rogers and Vinicius Junior, while Julian Alvarez never seemed realistic, the window closed, and Arsenal had effectively weakened their attacking options. The additions of Bruno Guimaraes and Ezri Konsa were definite plus points, as was the fee received for Martinelli.
However, Illan Meslier’s arrival as a third-choice keeper, with the mistake-laden Kepa Arrizabalaga, labelled as such thanks to his League Cup final nightmare against Manchester City, was not seen as good enough depth should a big problem befall David Raya. Meslier conceded at Fleetwood Town earlier in the season, which saw Arsenal eliminated in embarrassing fashion on penalties.
Some of the signings from 2025 have however so far shown not to be of starting quality for Arsenal. The evidence behind that is that despite playing plenty of minutes, there are others in the squad who, when fit, have still maintained their position.
Viktor Gyokeres and Eberechi Eze are the main pair, while Cristhian Mosquera’s low transfer fee and needing to compete with William Saliba and now Konsa, I think fairly rules him out of this debate, plus he has been good when called upon. Martin Zubimendi was a deal agreed under the former recruitment team prior to Berta’s arrival.
Piero Hincapie is second to Riccardo Calafiori, although he was brought in to be a competitive depth option, not a starter, as was Noni Madueke, who this season has seen a strong upturn in form. But Arsenal still want a striker who can upgrade on Kai Havertz and need a left winger after failing to sign another just three months ago.
Gyokeres was not Arteta’s first choice of centre-forward in 2025, and he preferred Benjamin Sesko, who proved too expensive and not willing enough to make the move to Arsenal, believed to want guarantees over playing time. Gyokeres was preferred by Berta, and the Swede was very keen on the move, willing to push it through and burn bridges with former club Sporting CP to make it happen, which certainly influenced many inside the club to get on board with the signing.
Eze meanwhile actually called Arteta, and work was done early in the summer window, but Nwaneri’s contract renewal caused the club to back off on their interest in the then-Crystal Palace talisman. It wasn’t until an injury to Havertz that a deal was done with Tim Lewis, the now-former executive vice-chairman, who was key in pushing for the move, while others in the club were calling for some restraint.
Eze and Gyokeres have so far failed to fulfil the desire to sign those two key forward players. It is Berta’s job again to try again and find the solutions.
But January is very difficult at any time to do business. Clubs are more reluctant to sell, the prices go up, you’re still tied to your financial fair play parameters from the summer, and there is no pre-season for new signings to bed in and adjust; they need to come in and immediately hit the ground running.
Arsenal have a strong transfer policy this summer which is being seen as somewhat risky
Andrea Berta and Mikel Arteta(Image: Alex Burstow/Arsenal FC via Getty Images)
View 3 Images
Arsenal are certainly interested in some major stars, but mainly ones who have high ceilings with some strong quality still to add immediately. Eli Junior Kroupi and Antonio Nusa are a key pair, while other players like Kevin Schade and Nicolo Tresoldi have also caught the attention of Arsenal’s recruitment team.
It will be up to Berta to overcome these obstacles and not leave Arteta without at least one forward many believe is a necessity when it comes to fighting on three fronts in the second half of the campaign. Berta’s role could even come under pressure if this window and the following summer window do not go to plan.
Some of Berta’s processes in the summer have raised eyebrows. The use of major intermediaries and agents to help get deals across the line.
Other Premier League clubs whose players became of interest to Arsenal in the summer were believed to grow frustrated with how the Gunners would go about business. Newcastle United were at the end of a protracted tactical pursuit regarding Guimaraes, whom they eventually sold for above what Arsenal initially wanted to pay, which was believed to be more than £20million lower initially, but still much less than the £100million initial asking price of the Magpies.
Aston Villa stood firm on their asking price for Konsa and would indeed extract £55million, with a small add-ons package included, from the North London club.
In the last year, Arsenal lost James Ellis, the former technical director, who would be replaced by Maurizio Micheli, an individual known well by Berta. Ellis was highly rated and well-respected in the game, and his exit was seen as a big loss for the club.
James King, the club’s head of football operations, has been very successful in helping the club tie down players to new deals such as Myles Lewis-Skelly. Although the youngster, as football.london broke in the summer, was the subject of interest from Chelsea and Manchester United, who were understood to have been approached about their potential interest in the player.
This occurred despite the player’s preference to remain at Arsenal, and who made his feelings clear when he scored in pre-season and gestured a heart to supporters in the stands. He would go on to score in the Community Shield and parade his medal to supporters in Cardiff, again hinting at his love for the club.
football.london understands Arsenal remain very interested in Bournemouth’s Alex Scott. While the likes of Mikel Merino and Zubimendi have been linked with exits, the arrival of Scott, for another huge sum, would certainly raise questions again of where Lewis-Skelly features, especially after the arrival and establishment of Guimaraes.
Even Zubimendi, who has been out of the side this season, remains fondly appreciated by Arteta, football.london understands. Merino has just over 18 months remaining on his contract.
Berta is increasingly under the microscope at Arsenal, and while Arteta has gained almost all of the faith of the fan base after winning the league, the Italian remains needing to prove his worth and show he can deliver the man credited as the catalyst for Arsenal’s revival to the elite level what he deserves and needs. This January window is a defining moment in Berta’s tenure and come February 1, there will be judgment.