espn.co.uk

Reranked: Who is the MVP for each of the top Premier League clubs?

play

Onuoha: Man United's two-year deal for Pochettino makes sense (1:18)

In March 2026, we delivered the sixth installment of our Premier League MVP rankings, aimed at tackling a mighty question: Which players rank as the most important at the division's top clubs?

We used a simple combination of ability and tactical factors to assess how crucial the players were to their teams and ranked the top 15 accordingly. Naturally, the best, most consistent and most present players filtered toward the top, while also allowing room for the most tactically crucial individuals to receive credit, too.

Now we've revisited the subject for a seventh installment, intrigued to see how things have changed. Football teams have to weather plenty of storms over the course of half a year, often changing, tweaking and recalibrating around injuries, absences and fluctuations in form.

So, we've reranked the players for another edition -- but this time, there are some major changes to the lineup. Firstly, Tottenham Hotspur have been dropped from the rankings, as they've spent too long circling the drain to warrant inclusion -- some might argue Manchester United deserve the same treatment, but they've hung on for now and, to be fair, they did finish third last season. Secondly, Manchester City's section looks very different as an earnest conversation around them as a club right now feels all but impossible.

Who are the best players on your club? See if you agree with our choices. Getty Images

Why 15? Well, with 11 first-team players starting any given match, this should allow for those squad positions that aren't 100% cemented. Any long-term injury absences will be noted separately and not considered for the ranking.

Who is eligible? The minimum minutes cutoff is 250 minutes, across Premier League, Champions League and League Cup action, which isn't a particularly high bar. That's in recognition of the fact that amid the increasingly congested schedule, even the top teams have to mix and match their XIs across the competitions to stay healthy.

How did you rate the players? A ranking like this will always be somewhat subjective, but efforts were made to consult experts on each club to help shape the rankings in accordance with our methodology.

Are stats involved? Statistics proved a powerful tool in backing up our assertions, with Opta's data used throughout and Gradient Sports' grades and physical data aiding the process, too. Please note that unless stated otherwise, all referenced statistics such as minutes played, goal contributions and tackles, etc. are a combination of Premier League and Champions League play.

How hard is it? Some of the decisions are glaringly obvious, but others not so much. Comparing players across different position groups is a difficult task. Within the context of a squad, though, it's possible to get a feel for who is the most integral.

I disagree wholeheartedly with your decision to put X below Y. Will you change it? Of course people will disagree, and a lot of this is subjective, but it's only a bit of fun.

Enough of that. On with the rankings.

0:32

play

ARSENAL

Arsenal's 2026 summer spend was much more considered and constrained than it was in 2025, as they sought to add quality -- not depth -- to the squad. On paper, that pointed to this edition of the rankings being a quiet one with few major movements, but the reality is very different. Key attacking players have returned to fitness while a slew of defenders have gone down with fresh injuries, creating major upheaval in this top 15.

MISSED THE CUT: The big name you won't see in this ranking is William Saliba, simply because he has not played a single minute so far this season. Martín Zubimendi, Piero Hincapié and Viktor Gyökeres have all seen their roles diminish significantly and therefore fail to make the cut. There's no Cristhian Mosquera, Eberechi Eze or Max Dowman either, while Leandro Trossard and Gabriel Martinelli departed the club over the summer.

15. Christos Tzolis (New!)

Tzolis signed in the summer to assume Trossard's role on the left wing, started fast in the Community Shield, and has offered goals, assists and work rate. He already looks like a player Mikel Arteta feels he can trust.

14. Mikel Merino (New!)

While only Martin Ødegaard has played in more games (16) than Merino (15) this season, the Spaniard has totaled just 518 minutes. That suggests Arteta always wants him to be involved in some capacity, but he hasn't been able to nail down a key -- or even starting -- spot so far this term. Merino's inclusion in this list means Eze misses out (despite playing a bit more), as he too has struggled to find top form.

All of ESPN. All in one place.

Watch your favorite events in the newly enhanced ESPN App. Learn more about what plan is right for you. Sign Up Now

13. Noni Madueke (=)

Just seven players have played more minutes (765) for Arsenal this season than Madueke, who is not considered one of the club's key players but has still been called upon liberally to cover for injuries and absences on the flanks -- most notably to Bukayo Saka and Tzolis.

12. Ben White (New!)

White's injury-ridden 2025-26 season is firmly in the rearview mirror. Watching him dovetail with Saka early this season brought back memories of the early Arteta days, where Arsenal's right side was king. But it's clear the England international is still the second choice at right back. Since Jurriën Timber finally regained full fitness in October, White has seen a lot less of the pitch.

11. Bruno Guimarães (New!)

Bruno Guimarães was signed for £75 million to take Arsenal's midfield up another notch, but we've seen nowhere near the best of him so far. He's lacked consistency, although injuries (and a drawn out summer) may well have played a part in that. That said, the Brazil international provides a base level of quality that most can't match, and he's scored a couple of crucial goals to ensure the Gunners collected maximum points from Leeds United and Sunderland. The best is yet to come, but Guimarães is already contributing to a winning machine.

10. Myles Lewis-Skelly (New!)

Lewis-Skelly made a super start to the 2026-27 season, creating a goal and dominating Manchester City during the Community Shield win. That made him difficult for Arteta to ignore despite having a glut of options at both central midfield and left back; he has mastered the use of his body in duels, carries the ball brilliantly and can pick a great pass. It's easy to forget he's still very young (20), and that for him to make this kind of impact on a team this good is something special.

9. Ezri Konsa (New!)

Arsenal are no longer reliant on Saliba's fitness, because Konsa has arrived to provide the depth Arteta has long craved at center back. After enjoying seven outstanding years at Aston Villa, the England international has seamlessly stepped up to the level the reigning champions have set. He's an outstanding one-vs.-one defender, covers huge spaces with ease, and keeps things simple on the ball. But with Saliba close to a return to fitness, the awkward conversations are about to commence.

8. Kai Havertz (New!)

Havertz is the clear and obvious first-choice No. 9 at the Emirates Stadium. Now that he's fit again, Arteta picks him wherever possible -- which means the man who led the line all season long in 2025-26, Gyökeres, has been sidelined. The Germany international will likely never be the prolific goal scorer some want (he's only scored three times this season), but he embodies what his manager wants in a forward: Technical, hard-working, able to link play and dovetail with the impressive midfield cast behind him.

7. Jurriën Timber (=)

Timber is back to full fitness and back in the XI. As good a right back as White is, there's no substitute for the level of quality the Netherlands international brings in every phase, and every area of the pitch. Arsenal's full backs are so multi-talented, Arteta is able to construct diverse systems that use players in so many different ways. Timber's equal levels of comfort defending one-vs.-one, moving into midfield, or overlapping into the opponent's box can all shine as a result.

6. Riccardo Calafiori (+8)

Speaking of multi-talented full backs, the list of things Calafiori can't do is far shorter than the list of things he can -- and Arteta is constantly tapping into that. The Italy international's heat map details how he splits his time between the flank and the center of the pitch, as he consistently tucks into midfield and then attacks down the middle.

You'll see him popping up in the spots you'd usually expect a No. 10 to, causing havoc among defenses as they try to track him. This multifaceted skill set has made Calafiori crucial to this iteration of Arsenal and, in turn, reduced Hincapie to a bench role for the time being.

5. Bukayo Saka (+1)

A quad injury sustained in October halted what had been an excellent start to the season for Saka. It was a bitter blow, as up until that point, he'd looked like someone who was comfortably shouldering the responsibility of leading the reigning champions in attack.

Arsenal can handle Saka's injuries better than before -- in Madueke, Tzolis and even Eze, who narrowly missed out on a spot in this top 15, they have wide creators in reserve who can keep the team afloat -- but it's still the case that Arsenal struggle to reach their deadly best without their No. 7.

4. David Raya (-1)

Raya drops one place in the ranking, but that's not a reflection of his performances. He remains the Premier League's best goalkeeper; a phenomenal shot-stopper, cross-claimer and passer rolled into one.

The Spain international isn't No. 1 for his country but he is a massive presence in this team and the last line of the league's best defense. However, goalkeepers can only have so much influence on a top team, so there are three others whose impact extends further.

3. Gabriel Magalhães (-1)

Gabriel suffers the same fate as Raya. He's a touch unfortunate to drop down a spot, as he's done extremely well to lead Arsenal's defensive line to a continued league-leading standard despite the upheaval of Saliba's injury.

His overwhelming goal threat from set pieces has dried up a bit, which was a core part of his value last season. Still, you'd struggle to point to a center back in the Premier League that has been definitively better than the Brazil international this term; he's played every minute so far for a team that have conceded just five goals.

2. Martin Ødegaard (+9)

It's been quite the roller-coaster ride on this list for Ødegaard, who is now -- finally -- back to where he should be: Playing a leading role for this Arsenal side.

The Gunners' captain was ranked ninth in March's edition and didn't even make the November version, as injuries had scuppered his playing time, then prevented him from reaching anything close to his top level. But he's back to it now; not only is he the team's top creator (35 chances, seven of which are big chances), he's also the joint top-scorer with four goals. There are games he has personally cracked open, such as the 1-0 win over Aston Villa in August, to ensure a three-point haul.

1. Declan Rice (=)

As impressive as Ødegaard has been, it's not enough to oust Rice from top spot in this ranking.

There were fears coming into the season that the England midfielder might struggle to find his top level due to being worked so hard by club and country across 2025-26, but those concerns have been allayed. He looks his usual irrepressible self striding through the center of the pitch, and tops the team for tackles (23) and goal contributions (6) in all competitions.

When you have a player who is this dominant physically, so influential defensively, and is outstripping the forwards for goals and assists ... there's nowhere else to place them but No. 1.

2:05

play

CHELSEA

Another new season, another new manager for Chelsea. Xabi Alonso now sits in the dugout, and it is hoped his appointment can represent a line in the sand, shifting the Blues away from their self-destructive tendencies and towards a period of stability and success. The Spaniard has installed his trademark 3-4-3 formation in west London which, alongside a predictably busy summer of ins and outs at the club, has pretty much turned the club upside down. Everything about the squad and the approach feels fresh, and that's reflected in these rankings.

MISSED THE CUT: Enzo Fernández, Marc Cucurella, Trevoh Chalobah, Robert Sánchez, Andrey Santos and Alejandro Garnacho all drop out of the ranking having left the club. Danny Welbeck, Malo Gusto, Valentín Barco, Mike Penders and, perhaps most controversially, Jorrel Hato, all miss out, as they've either struggled to impress or only enjoyed temporary importance to Alonso. None of Marco Palestra, Jamie Gittens, Emmanuel Emegha, or Geovany Quenda have played enough minutes to qualify.

15. Estêvão (-8)

Had this ranking been done in October, Estêvão would have dropped out entirely. His lack of involvement early in the campaign confused many, but he was given the nod against Manchester United and came out firing. Food for thought for Alonso.

14. Pep Chavarría (New!)

Chavarría's hold on Chelsea's left flank is slowly starting to solidify. The all-action Spaniard is a more natural fit for Alonso's wingback role than Hato and that is beginning to show.

13. Jordan Henderson (New!)

Plenty scoffed at Chelsea's decision to sign 36-year-old Henderson, but he has stepped into central midfield ably, played 537 minutes and even scored a belter of a free kick. It looks like he'll prove a useful veteran addition.

12. Josh Acheampong (New!)

Alonso has done exactly what Chelsea fans have been pleading for these last few years: Given Acheampong a proper run in the side. The defender has actually played the sixth-most minutes (851) of any Blues player this term, suggesting his manager is convinced by his current ability as well as his potential. It should be noted, though, that a couple hundred of those minutes came when Wesley Fofana was suspended, and once the France international became available he moved straight into the XI. There remains a pecking order in central defense and young Acheampong is only just starting to climb it.

11. Wesley Fofana (=)

That said, Acheampong can't be too far off stealing Fofana's status in this squad. If Fofana were a cat he'd be down at least seven of his nine lives, as injuries, off-field concerns and calamitous performances have too often set the narrative around him. His transfer from Leicester City cost Chelsea £70 million-plus in 2022 and they've understandably worked hard to try to glean value from that deal, but with Acheampong applying so much pressure, a changing of the guard could soon come.

10. Romeo Lavia (New!)

One of the feel-good stories at Stamford Bridge this season has been Lavia's emergence as a dependable footballer. He was signed from Southampton for a fee of £53 million plus add-ons in 2023, but spent his first three years suffocated by injuries, barely able to play at all.

However, preseason in 2026 went well and this term he has completed 90 minutes for Chelsea for the first time. In doing so, he reminded everyone how talented a midfielder he is, capable of evading the press, winning duels and progressing the ball under immense duress. The Belgium international has won more tackles and interceptions combined (25) than any other Chelsea midfielder; it's no wonder Alonso has taken to him and worked hard to remove any psychological barriers Lavia was struggling with in regard to his fitness.

9. Levi Colwill (New!)

Colwill spent most of last season sidelined with a torn ACL, so he's got the unenviable task of impressing a new manager while also working through a fair amount of ring-rust. There have definitely been some shaky moments and Colwill is nowhere near his best just yet, but Alonso is wisely giving him the time to find it, as his left-footed profile is ideal for the back-three system.

Finally, Chelsea moved to address their long-held weakness between the sticks, signing Martinez in what ended up a bargain £7.5 million deal from Aston Villa. Unfortunately, the Argentina international's start to life in west London was badly disrupted by a fractured jaw, sustained in a nasty collision with Everton's Jarrad Branthwaite. That makes him difficult to rank here: his impact has been negligible, but his established quality and status as the Blues' No. 1 goalkeeper warrants a top 10 selection.

In order to pull off certain formations, you need certain players. Alonso's 3-4-3 shape would not work without a specialist center back to play in the middle of the back three and Lacroix has been solid in the role since signing from Crystal Palace for £52 million in the summer. Any conversation about Chelsea's defenders this season takes place on a sliding scale of how error-prone they've looked, and we can safely say the France international has looked the least rickety -- he's only had one bad moment, whereas others have had several.

6. Pedro Neto (+1)

There are very few positions Neto can't play and very few blades of grass he won't cover. That versatility and work rate has traditionally been enough to endear him to pretty much any manager and Alonso is the latest in that line. The Portugal international has been deployed liberally, be it as a wing back, a striker, or something in between. His speed and directness always causes trouble for defenses and his three Premier League goals this season have been smart finishes.

5. Reece James (-4)

Not so long ago, Chelsea felt extremely reliant on their captain James. Last season they lost just 28% of their games with him in the team, but that number jumped up to 67% without him; it served as a marker of his quality and importance.

Given how injury-prone the 26-year-old is, though, that simply had to change this season. One of Alonso's biggest tasks was to enable this team to function without him and, to an extent, he's got them on the right path. When James returns from injury, big questions will abound over what position he plays moving forward. A man with his injury record simply cannot play wing back, so will he move full time to center back, central midfield or continue to straddle both?

4. Morgan Rogers (New!)

The top four in this ranking were difficult to split, and they represent a class unto themselves. These are the players who make Chelsea tick, and there's a big gap between them and James in fifth. Starting us off is Rogers, who joined the club for £117 million from Villa in the summer. He's been about as plug-and-play as you can get, immediately adapting to his new surroundings, and actually leads the Blues for goal contributions in all competitions with 10 -- although four of those have come in the Carabao Cup.

He and Cole Palmer -- boyhood friends from the Manchester City academy -- have enjoyed riffing off each other and quickly formed an excellent relationship on the pitch. Fourth might look harsh for Rogers given he's started so well, but there are three established, quality names ahead of him that require more time to usurp.

3. João Pedro (+1)

Pedro hasn't played for Chelsea since Oct. 17 due to injury, yet he still leads the club in terms of Premier League goals and assists (8). The attack simply has not looked right without him no matter who has filled in; be it Rogers, Welbeck or Emegha. His ability to drop in and connect play, feed his fellow forwards, then bolt into the box and finish reliably sets him apart. No other Blues forward can combine all of those qualities and make them sing within Alonso's system.

2. Moisés Caicedo (+1)

Caicedo's value to Chelsea's setup is clear, and if ever he is absent, it's hammered home even further. In order to get away with playing a genuine two-man midfield in the Premier League, at least one has to be an incredible athlete and a multi-faceted player, capable of covering ground, building attacks and destroying opponents' attempts to do the same. That player is Caicedo.

The Ecuador international largely missed the first eight games of the campaign due to injury, and while the Blues did get some results, the performances were pretty wonky at times. Since fully returning, starting with the 5-1 win at home to Bournemouth, things have stabilized somewhat.

1. Cole Palmer (+4)

He's now under considerable pressure from Rogers, Pedro and Caicedo, but at the end of the day, Palmer's name is still the first on the team sheet; this remains his team, with everyone else placed around him. He has clocked up 658 touches, the most of any attacking player, as Chelsea's game flows through him.

Palmer has converted those touches into eight goal contributions in all competitions. It's a good start, but there are pockets of Blues fans who still want more -- and it will be interesting to see what effect yet another snub from England manager Thomas Tuchel has on him. His shooting and ball carrying has impressed so far this season, but the real standout quality has been his passing -- he's played a handful of passes (notably against Brentford and Arsenal) that have cut right through the heart of even the most defensively organized teams.

1:17

play

LIVERPOOL

After years of impressive work with AFC Bournemouth, Andoni Iraola has been given a shot at the big time. Liverpool appointed him as their new manager to replace Arne Slot over the summer in a quest to liven up a flagging team, hoping for a return of the high-energy football Jürgen Klopp once produced at Anfield. The departure of several club mainstays and legends (such as Mohamed Salah) over the transfer window made that a tough task, but with the help of some fresh faces, the early results have been good enough to inspire some hope.

MISSED THE CUT: Mohamed Salah, Ibrahima Konaté, Andy Robertson and Curtis Jones all departed over the summer, so make way in the rankings, too. Due to injuries, Hugo Ekitike and Connor Bradley also drop out, automatically creating six empty spots in the top 15. Federico Chiesa and Giorgi Mamardashvili have barely played, and don't even feature in the cup. Joe Gomez, Jeremie Frimpong and Kostas Tsimikas do meet the minimum minutes threshold (250), but haven't done enough to earn a place. Backup forward Lewis Koumas might be the most unfortunate to miss out.

15. Ryan Gravenberch (-8)

It's been a slow, steady fall from grace for Gravenberch. He was immense in the first half of the 2024-25 season under Slot, but his form fell off a cliff in the new year and he has never recovered. The Netherlands midfielder doesn't really suit Iraola's tactical setup and has been usurped by 19-year-old Trey Nyoni.

14. Víctor Muñoz (New!)

Múñoz was signed as a depth winger who could rotate in and out and make an impact off the bench -- a role he's performed perfectly so far. His busy, energetic style is a good match for Iraola and he has netted two crucial goals against Nottingham Forest and Brentford.

13. Rio Ngumoha (New!)

Ngumoha is ready for takeoff. Liverpool's biggest challenge this season with the 18-year-old winger will be to manage his workload and expectations, because the potential he's flashing is wicked and the Anfield terraces are desperate to see him. He has bamboozled opponents with his incisive dribbling and found a home on the right side of Liverpool's attack, despite naturally preferring the left.

12. Trey Nyoni (New!)

This is Nyoni's breakout season. In the space of three months, he has gone from a young talent on the edge of the squad to a clear starter, totting up 618 minutes across 13 appearances so far. Passing is the 19-year-old's superpower: He leads all Liverpool players in line-breaking passes (12.09) on a per-90 basis, while he's also quickly become known for playing the right pass at the right time. He suits Iraola's midfield pivot better than Gravenberch, so has seemingly assumed his role.

11. Cody Gakpo (=)

Gakpo remains outside the top 10 as his position in Liverpool's squad has weakened over the last year. He was a favorite of Slot, but things have changed now and he's had to move over to the right flank to find playing time under Iraola. It has the look and feel of a stopgap -- either until Ngumoha is ready to play consistently, or until the club can finally secure their ideal transfer target in the months to come -- and has been linked with a move away.

10. Milos Kerkez (-1)

Kerkez and Iraola worked together brilliantly at Bournemouth, so it's no surprise to see the former assume the role of undisputed first-choice left back this season. Kerkez's energetic style, which sees him bound up and down the wing constantly, is a good fit for the system. He's far from an elite-level full back, but is a solid enough performer in a position that can be tough to fill.

9. Dominik Szoboszlai (-8)

In both editions of this ranking in the 2025-26 season, Szoboszlai was Liverpool's top-ranked player in terms of importance. How different things are today. The Hungary international is no longer the driving force of this team -- far from it, in fact. His form has suffered in 2026-27 (partly due to injury), and it's impossible to escape the feeling that Liverpool are less likely to control or win a game when he's on the pitch at the moment. Other midfield combinations are simply working better for the Reds, and Iraola has shown clear willingness to turn to them when required.

Bradley Barcola has arrived and slots in at No. 8 on the list. Alex Pantling/Getty Images

Any player whose transfer cost an initial €125 million should automatically become one of the most important players at their new club, but we can't say that about Barcola for now. The France winger has three assists in the Premier League and scored a hat trick against LASK in the Champions League -- a solid return, but there could and should have been more but for some big missed chances. In order to prove himself worth the transfer outlay, he'll need to step things up a notch, but it's very early days for the 24-year-old at Anfield and the flashes we have seen have been promising.

7. Ronald Araujo (New!)

One of the summer's more left-field transfers, Araújo's loan from Barcelona to Liverpool has worked out brilliantly so far. The Uruguay defender has stayed fit and been able to contribute consistently, taking command of the right back position for a team that badly needed a solution there. Used to playing as a center back, his physicality has allowed him to take to the Premier League with ease, while he's also showcased some surprisingly deft moments and flicks when getting forward.

6. Florian Wirtz (=)

Few players' performance levels have been debated as fiercely. Some insist Wirtz is now purring, with six goal contributions in all competitions the basis of that argument, while others say he still flatters to deceive. The truth is likely somewhere in the middle. The Germany midfielder is still not playing to a €100 million-plus level, as his transfer value suggests he should, but he has stepped things up under Iraola and become a more decisive figure in this team.

5. Alisson (-1)

Just last week, veteran goalkeeper Alisson provided a reminder of how critical he can still be, making a string of saves against Crystal Palace to keep Liverpool in the game ahead of an eventual 3-1 win. By Opta's measure, the Brazil international has prevented 1.54 more goals than expected based on the shots he's faced, which effectively ranks him seventh in the league for shot-stopping. The quality of the distribution with his feet seems to have dropped off a bit, so he's throwing and rolling the ball out more and more in response.

4. Jérémy Jacquet (New!)

Jacquet's performances belie his age and lack of experience. For a player who is yet to clock up even 50 appearances in Europe's top leagues to be playing this well, for an elite club, is incredible. The 21-year-old -- who arrived for €70 million from Rennes this summer -- is not only holding his own physically in the Premier League, but he's adding quality to Liverpool's buildup, as his punchy passes through the lines are setting the Reds off on attacks in a way his predecessor, Konaté, simply could not.

3. Alexis Mac Allister (+5)

Mac Allister struggled throughout the 2025-26 campaign, so Liverpool fans are relieved to see him performing well once again. His contract expires in 2028 and there's been no shortage of talk he could depart the club, but this rejuvenation could change the conversation again, and perhaps he could even earn a new contract? The Argentina midfielder is at his best when connecting to his teammates with quick passes and upping the tempo of the play. He has also posed a big threat on goal, often from range or using his head, netting five in all competitions so far.

2. Alexander Isak (New!)

Isak's first season at Anfield after joining in a British-record £125 million from Newcastle United was a disaster, arriving unfit, rarely impressing and then suffering a broken leg in December. But his second has gone a lot better: His seven goals from 10 Premier League appearances have pretty much kept Liverpool afloat in the table.

There is no better way to paper over the cracks of a team still adapting to a new style and system than simply scoring goals. Isak has provided a level of quality in the final third that no one else has in the squad (and few others in the Premier League can match), and it has made a huge difference to how the early months of Iraola's tenure will be viewed.

1. Virgil van Dijk (+1)

Last season offered a few hints that Van Dijk's powers were on the wane -- the 35-year-old defender was simply not quite so indomitable -- while this term, he's been rested for the odd cup game (an alien concept to Liverpool fans as, up until now, he's been as durable and relentless as they come.)

But despite this, the Netherlands international is once again Liverpool's most important player. His play may have dropped off, but he's still far better than most, while he's the clear and obvious standard-bearer in the dressing room and is now playing a vital role in helping Jacquet adapt to the Premier League. He tops all center backs in the division for aerial duel wins (79.2%) and ranks second for progressive passes (103).

1:57

play

MANCHESTER UNITED

Manchester United opted not to rock the boat in the dugout in the summer and award Michael Carrick the managerial job on a full-time basis. The thinking behind that was to keep the good times and strong form from last season rolling, but the reality has been much darker. The Red Devils failed to take any momentum and continuity into 2026-27, leading to a bad start, a lot of personnel tinkering, a faltering midfield and defense and, ultimately, Carrick's departure during the November international break. Parachuting in to pick up the pieces is Mauricio Pochettino, who left his post as USMNT manager to take on the task of guiding one of England's biggest clubs out of the relegation zone and back to prominence.

MISSED THE CUT: Only one player from March's edition, Casemiro, has left the club. Two more fall out due to a lack of minutes, Benjamin Sesko and Matthijs de Ligt, who have barely featured due to injury. Joshua Zirkzee remains on the periphery of the squad despite there being a lack of No. 9s, left back Patrick Dorgu has also barely featured because of injury, while young winger Shea Lacey has only made a fleeting impact from the bench.

15. Lisandro Martínez (-4)

When the chips are down, you want your experienced players to stand up. Instead, Martínez criticized the board publicly and got himself sent off against Chelsea, two acts that seriously harmed the club.

14. Noussair Mazraoui (New!)

The picture with Mazraoui remains the same as it ever has: He's a capable full back who can cover the left or the right, but injury issues often prevent him from gaining any real momentum.

13. Carlos Baleba (New!)

Baleba possesses the kind of physicality and dynamism that no other United midfielder does. On paper, that makes him a vital player, but in reality (so far), injuries have prevented him from taking a hold of this team. The Cameroon international will likely become a big presence for the Red Devils as the season wears on, but for the time being, he has played just 397 minutes, started just five times, and is yet to manage more than 72 minutes in a single game.

12. Marcus Rashford (New!)

An expensive, unexpected returnee from his loan at Barcelona, Carrick seemed obligated to find a way to integrate Rashford into the team, but that came at the expense of other strong attackers. In October, the winger sustained a hip injury and hasn't been seen since.

11. Youri Tielemans (New!)

Signed from Villa for £35 million over the summer and praised as a clever, bargain deal, expectations were ramped up, but so far he has not delivered. Much of the fault for that lies elsewhere, as this poorly constructed midfield has exposed his major weakness (a stark lack of athleticism) and made it difficult for his playmaking strengths to shine. He's played plenty, but has rarely looked close to his best level.

10. Leny Yoro (+4)

The good news is that Yoro is playing plenty, and if there's one thing every young player wants it's minutes. The bad news is that the France defender's form is struggling in tandem with the club's, and he's getting more playing time at right back than his favored role at center back.

9. Diogo Dalot (-2)

Dalot has played the fourth-most minutes (1,075) of any United player this season and recently passed the 250 appearance mark for the club. Love him or hate him (some fans booed him off the pitch against Villa), he's almost always fit and available to play -- which is more than you can say for every other full back at the club.

Diogo Dalot has played a lot for United but isn't very popular with some fans. Martin Rickett/PA Images via Getty Images

8. Amad Diallo (-2)

At his speedy best, Diallo is a menace on the wing. His pace and directness makes life tough for full backs, and his comfort in hugging the touchline stretches defenses into uncomfortable positions. The Ivory Coast international missed the first seven games of the season due to injury, but has started to ramp things up and showed signs against both Chelsea and Villa that he's finding form. In order to reach that next level, though, his production in front of goal needs to develop quickly.

7. Luke Shaw (-3)

Pochettino's arrival creates an intriguing reunion with Shaw; it was the Argentine who gave him his debut for Southampton back in 2012. But 14 years on, there's almost no chance Shaw can replicate his old rumbustious, rampaging full back role due to his history of injuries. True to form, he has missed the past seven games with a muscular problem. Before sustaining that he had been solid enough, though, which is more than you can say for the majority of his teammates.

6. Harry Maguire (+3)

Maguire is United's most-used center back this season, starting 12 games in all competitions. His major strength (75% aerial win rate) and major weakness (29.63 km/h max speed, per Gradient) are well established. He's committed a few odd mistakes, but by and large, his performance levels have been mostly fine. In the context of this United season that says quite a lot.

5. Senne Lammens (=)

Lammens was perhaps the Premier League's steadiest goalkeeper last season, playing consistently well in every area and rarely making a mistake. That continued into this season...until it didn't.

Over the last month or so he's looked very unsure of himself, misjudging a long ball in the swirling wind against Bournemouth then letting one through his legs against Villa. This, off the back of that big mistake in the 2026 World Cup knockouts for Belgium against Spain, has been enough to cause some concern among the fans. But for now, he stands pat in the top five, and perhaps Pochettino can construct a more functional defense, allowing Lammens to return to normality.

4. Kobbie Mainoo (+8)

Injuries have badly disrupted what otherwise has been a really positive campaign for Mainoo, who has been one of the few United players to find something approaching their best level. That propels him up this ranking almost by default.

According to Gradient, the 21-year-old ranks first among all Premier League midfielders for ball control, fifth for overall passing, and eighth for pressured passing. His tempo-setting skill set is one that Pochettino will surely savor, as he has always utilized a player like this throughout his career where possible.

3. Matheus Cunha (-1)

Cunha has split his time between striker, attacking midfielder and left winger this season -- and in certain moments has dropped to the bench while teammates are prioritized. It has felt a little bit like Carrick couldn't decide how to deploy him to full effect.

This isn't a question of Cunha's quality (he's excellent), but more a question of how he fits into an XI that features Bruno Fernandes, potentially Rashford and at times no natural striker. Fans have spent long hours debating how it all fits together and Carrick, apparently, was no different.

2. Bryan Mbeumo (+1)

Like last season, Mbeumo has been forced to deputize up front in the wake of Sesko's absence. The fact the Cameroon international can perform the role to a reasonable standard gives him extra value in this squad.

His return of five goals and assists so far this term is middling, but nestled in there are some key goals that have earned vital points against Everton, Leeds United, Tottenham Hotspur and Roma.

1. Bruno Fernandes (=)

For the seventh edition in a row, Fernandes occupies top spot for Manchester United. Realistically speaking, there has never been any other suitable choice.

As usual, he leads all Red Devils players by a distance in pretty much every attacking metric, including goal contributions (9), through balls (13), chances created (38) and line-breaking passes in the attacking third (58). Pochettino will undoubtedly seek to build his version of United around the Portugal midfielder, and might be wise to consult him when it comes to determining an initial playing style and intensity.

1:57

play

MANCHESTER CITY

Things are very different for Manchester City in this edition of the rankings. The complexion of their season was turned on its head in September, when it was announced that they had been found guilty of all charges related to serious financial breaches over a nine-year period. City deny wrongdoing and have appealed the verdict.

Watching them play ever since has been a curious experience; it's hard to know if any of it matters at all. Did their hot start (seven wins from seven games) in the Premier League mean anything, given there's a chance they could be handed a huge points deduction or even relegation in the months to come? And what do their recent losses mean? Are they in a tailspin? Does it even matter?

As a result, we've kept things extremely simple: We've listed City's 15 most valuable players according to Transfermarkt, as if their appeal fails, those numbers are the only ones that will matter, as a great exodus of stars will likely ensue.

15. Gianluigi Donnarumma (€45M)

T-13. Abdukodir Khusanov (€50M)

T-13. Rúben Dias (€50M)

T-11. Iliman Ndiaye (€65M)

T-11. Phil Foden (€65M)

10. Nico O'Reilly (€70M)

T-7. Jérémy Doku (€75M)

T-7. Josko Gvardiol (€75M)

6. Antoine Semenyo (€80M)

5. Ayyoub Bouaddi (€90M)

4. Rayan Cherki (€110M)

T-2. Enzo Fernández (€120M)

T-2. Elliot Anderson (€120M )

Read full news in source page