lead-art-block.fullscreen-enterExpandArsenal’s Kai Havertz, pictured, should have been given a penalty against Hull after being held, despite being in an offside position, the Premier League’s KMI Panel has found
Arsenal’s Kai Havertz, pictured, should have been given a penalty against Hull after being held, despite being in an offside position, the Premier League’s KMI Panel has found
The decision not to award a penalty to Arsenal against Hull for a foul on Kai Havertz while the German was in an offside position was incorrect, a panel has unanimously found.
Havertz was held back by Nobel Mendy in the match at the Emirates Stadium on November 7, but referee Farai Hallam gave nothing on field. VAR Michael Oliver recommended Hallam review the incident, but no penalty was given because of Havertz being in an offside position.
The five-person Key Match Incidents (KMI) panel was unanimous in its view that a penalty should have been given on field and after review due to the chronology of events.
Premier League Key Match Incidents (KMI) Panel – Match Round 10 outcomes.https://t.co/rinie0pS6K
— Premier League Match Centre (@PLMatchCentre) November 18, 2026
The panel determined that Mendy’s holding of Havertz occurred before any potential offside offence by the German. Law 11 says that a player in an offside position at the moment the ball is played or touched by a team-mate is only penalised on becoming involved in active play.
The panel also unanimously disagreed with the decision not to award a penalty to Coventry against Everton on November 6 when James Tarkowski pulled the hair of Caleb Yirenkyi.
The panel felt this should have been penalised and a yellow card shown to Tarkowski.
There was unanimous agreement with the decision to allow Manchester United’s equaliser in the 4-4 draw with Aston Villa on November 8 to stand.
A challenge by Manchester United goalkeeper Senne Lammens, in black, on his opposite number Zion Suzuki, in yellow, was not deemed impactful and worthy of disallowing United’s equaliser
A challenge by Manchester United goalkeeper Senne Lammens, in black, on his opposite number Zion Suzuki, in yellow, was not deemed impactful and worthy of disallowing United’s equaliser
Replays suggested United goalkeeper Senne Lammens may have impeded his opposite number Zion Suzuki as he challenged for the ball, but the panel were satisfied that the United man’s contact was not impactful and below the threshold for a foul.
The panel was divided on the challenge by Leeds’ Jayden Bogle on Tottenham’s Mathys Tel in their match on November 7. Two of the panel felt referee John Brooks should have red-carded Bogle and that VAR Tony Harrington should have intervened, but three felt that, while the contact was clearly reckless, it was below the threshold for a red card and backed the on-field decision and the decision not to intervene.
There have been 223 KMIs in the 10 match rounds so far, with 85 per cent of on-field decisions deemed correct, rising to 97 per cent after VAR intervention.