VAR Premier League
VAR Premier League
Arsenal thought they were about to get a penalty at the Emirates. Then the decision went the other way.
The Premier League has now published its official verdict on that first-half moment. It will not go down well with the officials.
The Key Match Incidents Panel has assessed the big calls from Match Round 10. One of them came in Arsenal’s win over Hull City.
READ MORE: ENDRICK TRANSFER TWIST AS ARSENAL REACH BRUTAL JANUARY VERDICT
The panel ruled that Arsenal should have had a penalty in the 42nd minute. Hull defender Nobel Mendy held Kai Havertz inside the box. Havertz was standing in an offside position at the time.
CLICK HERE TO JOIN THE NOW.ARSENAL WHATSAPP GROUP CHAT TO KEEP UP TO DATE WITH ALL THE LATEST NEWS!
The officials did not award a spot-kick. All five panellists said that on-field call was wrong, by a vote of 0-5. They also voted 0-5 that the outcome after the VAR review was wrong.
The panel did back the decision to send the referee to the pitchside monitor. It felt that part of the process was right. The mistake came in the decision that followed the review. It said the final call should still have been a penalty.
What the Premier League panel said
“Although Havertz is clearly in an offside position, there is a clear and impactful holding action by Mendy before any potential offside offence by Havertz,” the panel said.
“Given the chronology of events, a penalty should have been awarded. The panel considered the VAR intervention was correct; however, the outcome after the on-field review was considered to be incorrect as a penalty should have been awarded.”
The Premier League also explained the law behind the call. “Being in an offside position, in itself, is not an offence,” it said.
A player is only penalised once he becomes involved in active play. If a defender fouls him before that happens, the foul comes first. That is why the offside starting position did not cancel out the hold.
“If a player is fouled before becoming involved in active play, the foul is penalised as it has occurred before the offside offence,” the league added. “Therefore, in this instance, Arsenal should have been awarded a penalty.”
The incident was one of the cases highlighted in the weekly report. Across Match Round 10, the panel reviewed 27 referee incidents. It said 78 per cent of the on-field decisions were correct.
This season the panel has now reviewed 223 referee incidents. It has judged 85 per cent of the on-field calls to be right. After VAR, that figure rises to 97 per cent.
The Premier League published the verdict in its Match Round 10 Key Match Incidents report. You can read it in full on the league’s website.
In short, Arsenal should have had a spot-kick. The officials went to the screen and still got the call wrong. The result of the game does not change. But the panel has now said so in black and white.
Martin Zubimendi
Martin Zubimendi
Arsenal forward Gabriel Martinelli with Real Madrid's Vinicius Jr
Arsenal forward Gabriel Martinelli with Real Madrid's Vinicius Jr