arsenalcore.com

Five votes to nil: the Premier League’s panel says Arsenal were robbed of a penalty against Hull, and the offside call was wrong

Havertz vs Southampton

Havertz vs Southampton

The Premier League’s own referee panel has ruled that Arsenal should have had a penalty in the 1-0 win over Hull City, and that the offside call which took it away was wrong.

The Key Match Incidents Panel has gone through the big calls from Match Round 10, and the first-half moment at the Emirates Stadium is one of the cases singled out in its weekly report. The verdict could hardly be clearer: five votes to nil against the officials.

It changes nothing on the scoreboard. Martin Odegaard’s rebound 18 minutes from time had already won the game, as we covered in our Arsenal 1-0 Hull City match report. But it does settle an argument that left Mikel Arteta and most of the ground scratching their heads.

What happened with the Kai Havertz penalty against Hull?

In the 42nd minute, Kai Havertz went down in the box after Hull defender Nobel Mendy held him. Nothing was given on the pitch, so VAR sent referee Farai Hallam to the monitor.

The crowd expected a spot-kick. Instead, Hallam told the stadium that Havertz had been fouled, but that no penalty would follow because the German was already in an offside position. Arteta admitted afterwards that “we don’t have clarity on it”, and it is easy to see why.

How did the panel vote?

All five panellists said the on-field decision not to award a penalty was wrong, a 0-5 vote. They voted the same way, 0-5, on the outcome after the VAR review.

There is one small crumb of comfort for the officials. The panel agreed that VAR was right to send Hallam to the screen, so the process worked. It was the call he made once he got there that it could not support.

The panel explained it plainly: “Although Havertz is clearly in an offside position, there is a clear and impactful holding action by Mendy before any potential offside offence by Havertz. Given the chronology of events, a penalty should have been awarded. The panel considered the VAR intervention was correct; however, the outcome after the on-field review was considered to be incorrect as a penalty should have been awarded.”

Why offside did not cancel the foul

This is the part that tripped up the officials. Standing in an offside position is not an offence on its own. A player is only penalised once he becomes involved in active play, and Mendy’s hold came before Havertz did anything of the sort.

The Premier League spelled out the law: “Being in an offside position, in itself, is not an offence. If a player is fouled before becoming involved in active play, the foul is penalised as it has occurred before the offside offence. Therefore, in this instance, Arsenal should have been awarded a penalty.”

So the order of events decides it. Foul first, offside second, and the foul wins. Hallam had the right facts in front of him at the monitor and still landed on the wrong answer.

How often does the panel overrule the officials?

Across Match Round 10 the panel reviewed 27 refereeing incidents and judged 78 per cent of the on-field decisions to be correct. That was a poor week by the season’s standards.

Over the campaign so far it has looked at 223 incidents. It rates 85 per cent of the on-field calls as right, rising to 97 per cent once VAR has had its say. The Havertz decision sits in that small group that VAR could not rescue, even though it was the one that flagged it in the first place.

Verdict: a penalty Arsenal never needed, and a rule worth remembering

Arsenal got away with it this time because Odegaard found the net in the 72nd minute. Had that rebound gone wide, a wrongly cancelled penalty would have been the story of the weekend, and a ruling more than a week later would have been little consolation.

For us, there are two takeaways. First, the law is now on record: an offside position does not wipe out a foul that comes first, and Arsenal will have it in their back pocket the next time a similar call goes against them. Second, it does not let Havertz off completely. He was still ahead of play, and his habit of drifting offside, which we looked at in our piece on Kai Havertz’s offside count this season, is what put the referee’s decision in play at all.

Hull, who had set up so well to frustrate Arteta’s side, will feel they got the break that day. Arsenal will simply be glad it did not cost them two points.

Recommended for you

Read full news in source page