talksport.com

Premier League review of Arsenal penalty sparks calls for ludicrous rule to be changed

Arsenal are denied a penalty by VAR

The Premier League have revealed that Arsenal were wrongly denied a penalty against Hull earlier this month due to a bizarre rule.

As part of the latest review by the Key Match Incidents Panel (KMI), it was found that an incorrect decision was made during the Gunners' 1-0 win at the Emirates on November 7.

Kai Havertz pleads with referee3

The Premier League's KMI have found that Havertz and Arsenal were wrongly denied a penalty against Hull earlier this month

As Nobel Mendy pulled Kai Havertz's shirt in the box and brought the German down, a penalty was not originally awarded.

Referee Farai Hallam didn't point to the spot, but he was soon recommended to go over to the VAR monitor for a review.

The official watched the incident back, but the VAR on the day, Michael Oliver, alerted him to an offside in the build-up.

So, instead of changing his mind to give a penalty for the foul, Hull were given an indirect free-kick due to Havertz being offside.

Where to watch Newcastle vs Arsenal as Premier League introduce new feature for clashHaaland sparks pandemonium as Norway book quarter-final spot after historic comebackEFL player suspended from training over conduct with contract termination not ruled outSimon Jordan has perfect reaction to Campbell describing himself as an icon

However, that series of decisions made by referee Hallam and Oliver on VAR was wrong on both parts.

The Premier League's KMI found the on-field decision and VAR intervention to be incorrect in their review.

Havertz was in an offside position, but Mendy had pulled the Arsenal forward's shirt and fouled him before any offside offence.

And due to that order of events, a penalty should have been given.

IFAB Law 11 states that a player in an offside position at the moment the ball is played or touched by a team-mate is only penalised on becoming involved in active play.

Havertz had not become involved in the active play at the time Mendy brought him down, so the foul is penalised before the offside.

Kai Havertz and Martin Odegaard plead with referee3

Havertz was ruled to have been offside in the build-up before having his shirt pulled in the box by Hull's Mendy, with no spot-kick being awarded

Murphy calls for rule change

It is not the Premier League's admission that they got the decision wrong that has stoked debate, it is the unusual rule.

Jim White, Simon Jordan and Danny Murphy were joined by former top flight assistant referee Dan Robathan on talkSPORT.

And Robathan admitted that situations such as this one are tough to judge due to the laws: "If you look at Harry Kane, Sergio Aguero, they always used to stand offside, so where do you draw the line?

"It's a foul before its offside because you can't have a situation where someone is tripped up deliberately and you say he's offside and give a free-kick the opposite way, you wouldn't want that.

"I think this situation is on the borderline. I prefer an offside to be given, but that's not what the law says.

"So we have to go back to the law, which is there no offside offence that has been committed, he's in an offside position (which is) no offence, it's a penalty."

Kai Havertz with his hands on his head3

Even though Havertz was in an offside position, rules state that the penalty should have been given as the shirt pull happened before any offside offence

Calling for a change to the rules, Murphy then added: "But he's trying to gain an advantage by being offside to then go and score a goal.

"I think they've got it mixed up, the priority, the order in the law.

"The law should be you look at the offside first and then the foul second, not the other way around."

Read full news in source page