Newcastle have decided to leave St James' Park to build a new stadium
The controversial call will split fans, but it is ultimately the right one
LISTEN NOW: It's All Kicking Off! With the Premier League likely securing five Champions League spots, are we rewarding mediocrity?
By CRAIG HOPE
Published: 15:41 EDT, 13 March 2025 | Updated: 15:41 EDT, 13 March 2025
Newcastle’s plans to move to a new super stadium and leave behind St James’ Park will split opinion - on Tyneside and beyond - but it is the right call. Even if I do say that with a 51-49 rate of conviction.
St James’ is one of the richest in the land for story and tradition, the envy of the country for its iconic setting and fanatical atmosphere.
Colleagues from ‘down South’, here to cover the recent Carabao Cup semi-final win over Arsenal, could not believe the idea of leaving the ground was even being contemplated after a raucous night under the lights.
In response, I would offer this - you were lucky to be there, thousands more, with black-and-white allegiance, were not.
And that is my overriding motivation for being in favour of the move - tomorrow’s generation cannot be locked out.
Yes, there is the business argument that the club will make - increased matchday revenue leading to a better team and more success.
St James' Park has been Newcastle's home for 133 years and is the envy of the country
The fanatical atmosphere lifts Eddie Howe's men and some cannot understand why the club would want to leave
But building a new stadium away from St James' will allow more fans to see their beloved Newcastle play, and that trumps everything - even the money involved
If the Saudis want to be number one in the world, as is their stated ambition, they’ll only get there by building a new stadium. PSR makes that a harsh reality.
But forget finances. This, for me, is about inclusion, getting as many boys and girls and men and women into the stadium to watch their team.
The club are calling it a ‘once-in-a-generation cheque’ that PIF will have to sign. I’d call it a once-in-a-generation opportunity.
This, of course, is all on the proviso that they get the build right. The Leazes Park location is perfect, preserving the matchday tradition of a few beers in town before climbing the hill, and rolling back down on full-time.
Now, it’s about design, acoustics, retaining identity and forging a new one. It’s exciting and it’s the right move.
At least, I think it is.
Newcastle United