French President Emmanuel Macron has called on European nations to rethink their reliance on American-made military hardware, urging them to replace Lockheed Martin’s F-35 fighter jets with France’s Rafale and swap out the U.S.
Patriot air defense system for the Franco-Italian SAMP/T, according to an interview published on March 14, 2025, by Le Parisien and Nice-Matin. Speaking from Paris, Macron made his pitch during a time of shifting transatlantic dynamics, as European countries face growing pressure to bolster their own defense industries amid uncertainties in U.S. foreign policy following Donald Trump’s return to office in January.
His remarks aim to convince NATO allies and other European partners to buy European, boosting jobs and autonomy while countering what he sees as an overdependence on American technology that’s been a cornerstone of the continent’s security for decades.
The timing of Macron’s statement ties directly to recent geopolitical shifts. With Trump’s administration signaling a possible pullback from NATO commitments—echoing his first term’s skepticism about the alliance—European leaders have been debating how to strengthen their own defenses.
Macron, long a champion of European strategic autonomy, seized the moment to push his case. “We must offer European alternatives to countries accustomed to American equipment,” he told the French newspapers, pointing to the Rafale, built by Dassault Aviation, and the SAMP/T, developed by Eurosam, a joint venture between France’s Thales and Italy’s MBDA.
He argued that scaling up production of these systems could lower costs and create a self-sustaining defense network across Europe, less tethered to Washington’s priorities.
The Rafale, a twin-engine multirole fighter, has been France’s flagship warplane since it entered service in 2001. Unlike the stealth-focused F-35, which relies heavily on its low radar profile, the Rafale emphasizes versatility—capable of air-to-air combat, ground strikes, and reconnaissance with a top speed of Mach 1.8 and a combat radius of about 1,000 miles.
Macron’s pitch comes as several European nations, including Poland and Finland, have opted for the F-35 in recent years, drawn by its advanced sensors and NATO interoperability. Poland, for instance, signed a $4.6 billion deal in 2020 for 32 F-35s, while Finland ordered 64 in 2021, per U.S. State Department records.
France, which never pursued the F-35, sees the Rafale as a proven alternative, with over 200 delivered to its own forces and exports to countries like India and Egypt.
The SAMP/T, meanwhile, is a ground-based air defense system designed to shoot down missiles and aircraft at ranges up to 75 miles. It’s equipped with Aster 30 missiles and a radar that can track multiple targets, making it a competitor to the Patriot, which has a longer range—up to 100 miles—but comes with a higher price tag and complex maintenance needs.
Ukraine’s success with Patriots against Russian jets, widely reported by outlets like Reuters, has cemented its reputation, but Macron wants Europe to bet on the SAMP/T instead. France and Italy have already supplied one system to Ukraine in 2023, and a second is in the works, according to Militarnyi, a defense news site.
Macron’s vision is to expand its use across the continent, replacing the dozens of Patriot batteries operated by nations like Germany and the Netherlands.
Reactions to Macron’s proposal vary across Europe. French Defense Minister Sébastien Lecornu backed the idea, telling France Info Radio that European taxpayers’ money should stay in Europe, not flow to American firms.
He highlighted that France plans to order 42 more Rafales in 2025, per a €50.5 billion defense budget, and is pushing Eurosam to streamline SAMP/T production. But not everyone’s on board.
Polish officials, speaking anonymously to Politico, said their F-35 deal is locked in, citing its integration with U.S.-led NATO operations as a non-negotiable advantage. “We’re not turning back now,” one source said, reflecting a broader sentiment among Eastern European nations wary of Russia and reliant on American security guarantees.
The numbers tell part of the story. The F-35 program, managed by Lockheed Martin, has sold over 900 jets worldwide, with European orders making up a chunk of that, according to the company’s 2024 annual report.
Each jet costs around $80 million, though maintenance and training push the lifetime price much higher—up to $1.7 trillion for the U.S. fleet alone, per a Government Accountability Office estimate. The Rafale, by comparison, runs about $70 million per unit, with Dassault claiming lower operating costs due to its simpler design.
On the air defense side, a Patriot battery costs roughly $1 billion, including missiles, while a SAMP/T system is closer to $600 million, per industry figures cited by Defense News. Macron’s argument hinges on these savings scaling up if more countries buy-in.
History offers context for his push. France has long resisted American dominance in arms sales, opting out of the F-35 program in the early 2000s to protect its aerospace sector. The Rafale struggled early on, losing bids to U.S. jets in places like the Netherlands and Switzerland, but recent wins—like Greece’s 24-plane order in 2021—have bolstered its case.
The SAMP/T, too, has faced skepticism, with only France and Italy as primary users until Ukraine’s deployment proved its worth. Posts on X from defense watchers like DefenceGeek praised its performance there, noting it downed a Russian missile in March 2023, a feat confirmed by Ukraine’s Air Force.
Across the Atlantic, the U.S. response has been muted but pointed. A State Department spokesperson, quoted by CNN, said America welcomes European defense investment but stressed that NATO’s strength lies in shared systems like the F-35 and Patriot. “Interoperability matters more than ever,” the official said, hinting that a shift to European alternatives could complicate joint operations.
Lockheed Martin and Raytheon, the Patriot’s maker, declined to comment directly on Macron’s remarks, though both companies have lobbied hard to keep European contracts. A 2024 Raytheon brief to Congress touted the Patriot’s 240-plus intercepts globally as unmatched by any rival.
European leaders are split on the idea. German Chancellor Olaf Scholz, speaking at a Munich security conference earlier this month, acknowledged the need for more European production but stopped short of endorsing Macron’s specific swap. Germany’s 12 Patriot batteries, some headed to Ukraine, are a big investment, and switching would mean retraining crews and rethinking logistics.
Italy, a SAMP/T co-developer, is more receptive—Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni told reporters in Rome that she’s open to talks, especially if it means jobs in Turin and Milan. Smaller nations like Portugal, which recently paused an F-35 decision, might be Macron’s best shot, per a Defense Procurement International report.
Analysts see both sides. “Macron’s got a point about sovereignty,” said Sophia Besch of the Carnegie Endowment in a recent webinar. “But the F-35’s tech edge and NATO compatibility are tough to beat.” She noted that the Rafale lacks the stealth of its American rival, a gap Dassault says it offsets with electronic warfare upgrades.
On air defense, the SAMP/T’s shorter range limits its appeal against long-range threats like Russia’s hypersonic missiles, a concern raised by Bronk of RUSI in a Defense One piece. Still, Besch added, cost and politics could sway some buyers if France sweetens the deal with financing or joint production.
Macron’s not just talking—he’s acting. He’s pressed Thales and Dassault to cut red tape and lower prices, a move Lecornu said could drop Rafale costs by 10% if orders rise.
Posts on X from FrenchDefTech speculated that a new SAMP/T variant, teased at a Paris air show last year, might extend its range to 100 miles, closing the gap with Patriot. Meanwhile, the U.S. isn’t standing still—Lockheed’s pushing an F-35 Block 4 upgrade with better sensors, set for 2026, per Aviation Week.
The debate’s far from settled. Europe’s spent over $100 billion on U.S. arms since 2014, per SIPRI data, a trend Macron wants to reverse. Whether he can convince enough capital to ditch the F-35 and Patriot for Rafale and SAMP/T depends on more than specs—it’s about trust, budgets, and how much risk countries are willing to take on their own.
***
Follow us everywhere and at any time. BulgarianMilitary.com has responsive design and you can open the page from any computer, mobile devices or web browsers. For more up-to-date news, follow our Google News, YouTube, Reddit, LinkedIn, and Twitter pages. Our standards: Manifesto & ethical principles.