NFL legend Steve Smith Sr. has never been one to shy away from sharing his unfiltered opinions, and his recent comments on the "J-Villains Podcast" have sparked plenty of debate. While discussing the top wide receiver prospects for the 2025 NFL Draft, Smith surprised many by expressing reservations about Arizona's standout WR, Tetairoa McMillan.
McMillan, widely regarded as a top-10 prospect, has been celebrated for his size, athleticism, and football IQ. However, Smith pointed out areas where he believes McMillan falls short. "He's got all the tools, but he leaves a lot of plays on the field," Smith said during the podcast. "When you're looking for a WR1, you need someone who's consistent, who fights for every ball, every down. I don't always see that with him."
Smith's critique centered on McMillan's tendency to take plays off when he isn't the primary target, as well as his limited release package against press coverage. While acknowledging McMillan's potential, Smith emphasized that the young receiver needs to refine his game to succeed at the next level.
The comments have sparked a mix of reactions from fans and analysts. Some agree with Smith's assessment, while others argue that McMillan's upside outweighs his current flaws. As the draft approaches, McMillan will have the chance to prove the doubters wrong and solidify his status as one of the premier talents in this year's class. For now, Smith's words add an intriguing layer to the pre-draft conversation.
Related: Jerry Jeudy's Four-Word Response To Steve Smith Sr.'s Rant Is Turning Heads
Copyright 2025 Athlon Sports. All rights reserved.
This story was originally published March 18, 2025 at 5:16 PM.