As Leeds United head into the business end of the EFL Championship season, manager Daniel Farke is faced with several important tactical decisions that could determine whether his side earns automatic promotion back to the Premier League. One of the most debated topics among fans is who should occupy the No. 10 role in Farke’s attacking system – Brenden Aaronson or Wilfried Gnonto.
After an impressive showing as a half-time substitute against QPR, many supporters were calling for Willy Gnonto to replace Aaronson to play in behind Joël Piroe. Gnonto’s directness, technical ability, and unpredictability gave Leeds a new attacking dimension in that second half, prompting questions over whether his explosive style is better suited to unlocking stubborn Championship defences.
Gnonto’s Misfortune Post-QPR
However, just as the Italian seemed poised to stake his claim for a starting role, an unfortunate international break with Italy U21s brought that momentum to a halt. Gnonto struggled for form during the international fixtures, with La Gazzetta dello Sport, among others, criticising his performances.
The Leeds winger was labelled “invisible” and “unconvincing,” prompting further concern when he picked up a knock in the process. According to Leeds Live, the criticism from national media reflects a difficult period for the 20-year-old, who will now need to rebuild confidence and fitness in a crucial stage of the season.
This opens up a more serious discussion — is the criticism of Brenden Aaronson fair, or is he still the right man to lead Leeds’ attacking midfield?
Aaronson’s Role In Farke’s System: More Than Just Energy
Despite making a costly error that led to QPR’s opener before being substituted, Brenden Aaronson still holds key attributes that align with **Daniel Farke**’s tactical blueprint. Importantly, Aaronson stayed behind during the international break, giving him valuable rest and time on the training ground — something that may prove critical in a congested end to the campaign.
In Farke’s preferred 4-2-3-1, the No. 10 must do more than just provide flair — the role demands relentless pressing, ball retention under pressure, and clever movement to disrupt defensive structures. Aaronson, known for his high-octane, intelligent play, fits this mould.
His ball-carrying ability, decision-making under pressure, and willingness to press aggressively from the front make him a tactical asset in Leeds’ counter-pressing system. He might not always produce the final ball, but his presence knits together the phases of attack, particularly in transitions.
Aaronson VS Gnonto: Who Should Start At 10?
Brenden Aaronson
Aaronson brings relentless energy and tactical intelligence to the No.10 role. His strengths lie in his high pressing, excellent dribbling in tight areas, and sharp positional awareness. He’s also a strong ball carrier, capable of driving through midfield at pace and linking play effectively. Importantly, his versatility allows him to drop into a midfield three or push higher to support the striker, offering Farke tactical flexibility.
However, while Aaronson’s work rate is unmatched, he can lack end product. His contributions in terms of goals and assists have been inconsistent as of late, and his decision-making in the final third sometimes leaves Leeds without the cutting edge needed in tight games.
Wilfried Gnonto
Gnonto offers a different profile altogether — one built on flair, fearlessness, and technical finesse. His pace, dribbling, and close control make him a real threat in one-on-one situations. He excels at receiving the ball between the lines, cutting inside from wider positions, and creating chances with quick, incisive play. His direct style and creativity could add an unpredictable spark to Leeds’ attack.
That said, Gnonto’s defensive work rate and positional discipline aren’t as strong as Aaronson’s. He’s most effective when he has space to exploit, which is often limited when operating centrally against compact Championship defences. Deploying him at 10 would require further tactical tweaks to maintain the team’s defensive shape and pressing structure.
Rotation And Squad Depth Could Be The Deciding Factor
For Daniel Farke, the end-of-season run-in will demand smart rotation and squad management. With Manor Solomon and Dan James continuing to impress in wide areas, Leeds have a strong attacking unit with depth and variety across all attacking areas.
The Aaronson vs Gnonto debate is a good problem to have — and one that highlights the wealth of options at Farke’s disposal. If he gets the tactical balance right and uses the squad intelligently, Leeds United will be well positioned to push for automatic promotion and a return to the Premier League.