Tomas Soucek is one of those players who divides opinion more than most.
The Czech international arrived at West Ham United in 2020 with plenty of promise, and his first couple of seasons were marked by consistent performances and crucial goals, particularly in the defensive and attacking boxes.
However, in recent times, Soucek’s role has been called into question, with Everton reportedly keen to reunite him with his former manager, David Moyes. So, is he a legend in the making or a liability for West Ham? Let’s dive into the paradox of Tomas Soucek.
The Rise of Soucek: A Midfielder Who Can Do It All
When Soucek first joined West Ham, he quickly established himself as a physical force in the middle of the park. His towering presence in both boxes was immediately noticeable, and he quickly became known for his aerial ability, especially from set pieces.
He wasn’t just a defensive asset either - he was scoring goals at a regular clip. In fact, his first season at West Ham was a revelation, with Soucek contributing heavily in both defensive and attacking duties, even getting into double figures for goals from midfield.
Fans were thrilled. The team had found a box-to-box midfielder who could break up opposition attacks, win headers in both halves of the pitch, and score important goals. This made Soucek an instant fan favourite - his style was direct, no-nonsense, and it seemed like he was the answer to many of the team’s midfield problems.
The Paradox: Strong in Both Boxes but Lacking in the Midfield
Fast forward a couple of seasons, and things have become a bit more complicated. Soucek is still a physical presence, but the issue with his game now is his overall performance in the central midfield role. Despite being brilliant defensively and reliable in the opposition’s box, he’s often found wanting in the actual midfield, where West Ham need him most.
Defensively, there’s no doubt about his quality. His tackling and positional awareness are excellent, and he can break up attacks with ease. His presence in the air, especially on set pieces, continues to be a huge asset. However, it’s when he’s tasked with controlling the game in the middle of the park where he starts to struggle.
His passing range isn’t the most creative, and his ability to dictate the tempo of a match has been questioned, especially when playing against more technical sides. For all his work rate and energy, Soucek doesn’t seem to have the vision or composure to act as the lynchpin in the middle of the field.
This gap in his skillset has led to some fans viewing him as a liability. While his work ethic and contributions in the defensive and attacking thirds are invaluable, his lack of control and distribution in the midfield can sometimes slow down the team’s build-up play.
West Ham’s reliance on a deeper-lying playmaker and someone with more technical quality has become more apparent as the Premier League’s pace and intensity have increased.
The David Moyes Connection and Everton Rumours
With Everton reportedly interested in signing Soucek and reuniting him with David Moyes, it’s clear that his future at West Ham is uncertain. Moyes was the manager who brought him to the club, and it was under his guidance that Soucek flourished. A reunion could potentially benefit both the player and the manager, as Moyes knows how to get the best out of the Czech international.
For Everton, a move for Soucek could add some much-needed height and power in the midfield, which has been a weakness for the Toffees in recent seasons. However, there’s also a risk that Soucek’s lack of technical quality could be exposed in the high-tempo Premier League, especially in a team that might not be as defensively solid as West Ham.
The Debate: Liability or Legend?
The question that persists is whether Soucek’s performances are enough to make him a legend at West Ham. His early contributions, particularly his goals from midfield and defensive solidity, certainly earned him a place in the hearts of many fans. Yet, the criticism surrounding his midfield play is hard to ignore.
There’s a strong argument to be made that Soucek has been an unsung hero in certain aspects of West Ham’s rise to Premier League stability, but his lack of progression in the midfield role has led to growing frustration among sections of the fanbase. As the team looks to evolve and move beyond the Moyes era, it’s unclear whether Soucek fits into the club’s long-term vision.
In terms of the “legend” status, Soucek has undoubtedly made a positive impact. He may not be remembered as the most technically gifted midfielder in West Ham’s history, but his work rate, goals, and crucial contributions have been integral to the team’s success over the past few years.
Whether or not he can become a true West Ham legend, though, may depend on his ability to adapt and find more consistency in the areas where he’s currently lacking.
The Verdict
Is Tomas Soucek a liability or a legend for West Ham? Well, it’s a bit of both.
His contributions to the team’s success cannot be understated, particularly his physical presence and ability to pop up with vital goals. However, his limitations in the midfield role have led to concerns that he’s not the complete package that West Ham need to progress to the next level.
Whether he stays or moves to Everton, the question of his legacy at West Ham remains unresolved. He might not be a legend in the traditional sense, but his influence on the pitch is undeniable, even if it’s a bit of a paradox.
In the end, West Ham fans will likely continue to love him for his efforts in both boxes, but whether he’ll ever truly conquer the midfield remains to be seen.
* Like to share your thoughts on this article? Please visit the KUMB Forum to leave a comment.
* Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the highlighted author/s and do not necessarily represent or reflect the official policy or position of KUMB.com.