Villa soon had a chance to restore their lead when Devaney’s loose pass allowed them to surge into the United area. Murdock brought down his man as he tried to smother the danger, but then watched Borland strike the spot-kick well wide to keep the scores level.
Murdock came up big early in the second half to deny Mason Cotcher from close range before Proctor did the same when Obi’s snapshot came at him minutes later. Murdock again proved his shot-stopping class with another close-range denial, this time of Jamaldeen Jimoh-Aloba, cutting in from the left side of the box.
United made three substitutions, seeking more in the final third, and the first, Zach Baumann, nearly provided it with a whipping shot destined for the top left corner until a deflection. The Ukrainian youth international found space for another effort soon after which drew a fantastic save from Proctor. Obi’s header struck the right post from the subsequent corner.
Villa showed their threat primarily on the counter, with United forced into some uncertain last-ditch defending but ultimately keeping Murdock’s goal safe.
While United dominated the majority of the second half, it was Villa who controlled the first half of extra-time. Previously showing tiredness, they managed to retain possession well and then carve out chances, with Max Jenner shooting over before Murdock saved twice with relative comfort.
At the other end, United began to build momentum before the brief pause, but Jim Thwaites’ free-kick cross was well cleared. Shortly after the restart, another free-kick — this time shot direct — went wide of the right post.