The Pittsburgh Steelers cannot hide from the spotlight in 2025. After an offseason that left fans confused and national media intrigued, eyes are locked on a franchise that’s historically obsessed with winning. Gone are some familiar faces.
In their place? Unproven rookies, tasked with carrying the torch. It’s a high-stakes gamble — but one that could pay off with the right blend of veteran leadership and fresh talent.
I believe this rookie class has what it takes to contribute. With a few days of intense OTAs now in the books, these rookies are already carving out their identities. Here are a few early superlatives that fit this group as the Steelers inch toward the regular season:
Pittsburgh Steelers rookies earn superlatives during opening days of OTAs
Most Likely to Become a Starter: Kaleb Johnson, RB
Let’s be honest — the buzz around Kaleb Johnson is completely warranted. Selected in the third round, Johnson might go down as the Steelers’ most valuable pick in the 2025 NFL Draft. He’s already turning heads in OTAs with his burst, vision, and ability to contribute in the passing game. This offense lacked a dynamic backfield weapon behind Jaylen Warren last season, and Johnson offers that missing spark.
Whether he earns the RB1 role or thrives as a rotational back, I fully expect him to see significant touches early. He looks natural in Arthur Smith’s scheme, showing patience and power when needed. His pass-catching ability gives Pittsburgh something it’s lacked from the backfield for years. Simply put, the kid looks ready.
Most Likely to Be Studious: Will Howard, QB
With the quarterback room narrowed down — Mason Rudolph poised to start and no sign of Aaron Rodgers — the sixth-round pick out of Ohio State, Will Howard, finds himself in a perfect spot. This is not the year to throw him into the fire. Instead, it’s time to learn.
The Steelers learned their lesson with Kenny Pickett. Rushing a quarterback into action before he’s ready can ruin development. Howard should use this year to study film, absorb Arthur Smith’s offense, and learn from Rudolph’s poise. Every rep, every meeting, every mental rep matters. He’s got the mindset and football IQ — now he needs the time.
Most Likely to Make the Biggest Impact: Darrick Harmon, DT
Defense is the foundation in Pittsburgh. It always has and will be. In Darrick Harmon, the Steelers may have found their next defensive cornerstone. The first-round pick is already flashing through OTAs, showing power, quickness, and a relentless motor.
Cameron Heyward may still be the emotional leader of the unit, but he’s not getting younger. Harmon looks like he’s ready to rotate in from Week 1 and eventually take over the lion’s share of snaps. I expect him to make plays early and often, especially when the offense sputters.
He’s got all the tools to become a force up front — and maybe even a candidate for Defensive Rookie of the Year.
These aren’t just placeholders — they’re pivotal pieces of a puzzle Pittsburgh is trying to solve. The 2025 rookie class may be young, but they’re entering a system that will demand their best. So far? They’re rising to the challenge.
More Steelers News and Analysis