CLEVELAND, Ohio — The controversy started innocently enough – a throw from rookie quarterback Shedeur Sanders to Kaden Davis in the back of the end zone during OTAs. Was it a touchdown? Cleveland’s local media debated the call extensively before ruling it incomplete based on photographic evidence.
But the ensuing social media firestorm revealed something far more significant: the extraordinary level of scrutiny surrounding every move Sanders makes compared to his fellow quarterbacks.
“Everything Shedeur does is getting overanalyzed and everything he does is getting reacted to in a way that it’s just not going to happen with other quarterbacks or at least any other quarterbacks on this roster,” explained Dan Labbe of cleveland.com during the Orange and Brown Talk podcast.
This hyper-analysis extends beyond social media to national media outlets, with some already positioning Sanders as the Browns’ potential Week 1 starter – a notion that seems disconnected from what’s actually happening at practice. The fifth-round pick remains firmly fourth in the quarterback pecking order behind veterans Joe Flacco, Kenny Pickett, and fellow rookie Dillon Gabriel.
“We are seeing a lot of national media speculate that Shedeur is going to be the Week One starter. And we’re here boots on the ground and people don’t necessarily want to hear the truth, but I think we’re giving you the truth here from Cleveland,” said Mary Kay Cabot, who has observed every practice.
The disconnect between national narratives and local observations raises questions about motivation. Are certain stories being leaked strategically to boost Sanders’ profile for reasons beyond his on-field performance?
“I heard somebody say that they didn’t see a ball hit the ground (in rookie minicamp). I’ve got a video of the ball hitting the ground on a Shedeur throw,” Labbe noted. “I guess I get a little bit, like it’s the Brian Windhurst meme. The why would they do that? Why would that be out there? I just, it perks my ears up a little bit. Are they maybe pumping up Shedeur Sanders for other reasons?”
The Browns’ front office, known for its strategic approach to roster management, understands the value of the quarterback position. With four quarterbacks currently on the roster, speculation exists about whether certain narratives serve ulterior motives.
“When you have four quarterbacks, they know the value of the position. They know how quickly the landscape in the NFL can change if somebody gets hurt,” explained Ashley Bastock. “I think Andrew Berry and this front office knows how beneficial it would be to hold on to all four of these guys as long as humanly possible and see if you can get something for one of them.”
What’s clear amidst the speculation is that Sanders has shown genuine talent. He’s displayed accuracy, touch, and solid fundamentals that have impressed observers. By most accounts, he’s outperformed Gabriel in their limited opportunities, despite facing lesser competition.
The Sanders storyline ultimately reflects the unique dynamics of NFL quarterback competitions – where perception, draft position, media narratives, and on-field performance create a complex web that extends far beyond simple depth chart positioning.
As training camp approaches, the question remains: Will Sanders’ actual development match the extraordinary level of attention he’s receiving? Or will the hype machine continue to operate independently from what’s happening on the practice field in Berea?
Here’s the podcast for this week:
Listen and subscribe to the Orange and Brown Talk podcast on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.
Football Insider newsletter free trial: Take a minute and sign up for a free trial of our Football Insider newsletter, featuring exclusive content from cleveland.com's Browns reporters.
Note: Artificial intelligence was used to help generate this story from the Cleveland Orange and Brown Talk Podcast by cleveland.com. Visitors to cleveland.com have asked for more text stories based on website podcast discussions.