Manchester United are coming off a season filled with frustration, where isolated mistakes often had outsized consequences. While the team showed glimpses of quality, they faltered at crucial moments, largely due to costly errors in key areas. One player who has come under intense scrutiny is André Onana.
His mistakes in several high-stakes matches not only drew internal criticism but also cost the team valuable points, pushing them further from their objectives. With a new season approaching, the club’s leadership is seriously considering changes in the goalkeeping department in search of greater stability and authority at the back.
According to [The Mirror](https://www.mirror.co.uk/sport/football/transfer-news/man-utd-emi-martinez-transfer-35338710), United began discussions with Emiliano Martínez six months ago. The Aston Villa shot-stopper and World Cup winner has been under continuous observation, and in recent weeks, contact between the two parties has intensified. United are reportedly prepared to make a significant move for Martínez, but only if Onana’s future is resolved first. The club has made it clear that any transfer hinges on the Cameroonian’s situation. For now, Martínez remains focused on international duty with Argentina as they prepare for World Cup qualifiers against Chile and Colombia, delaying any immediate progress in negotiations.
Will Manchester United be able to sign Emiliano Martinez?
United’s interest in Emiliano Martínez comes as no surprise. His profile aligns closely with several key traits that Rúben Amorim values in his 3-4-2-1 system: a commanding presence in the box, composure with the ball at his feet, and strong leadership under pressure.
Martínez brings not only experience on the biggest stages, including a World Cup triumph, but also a level of confidence and personality that can galvanise those around him. His ability to stay composed in high-stakes moments makes him an ideal fit for a squad aiming to rebuild its mental and tactical resilience.
In Amorim’s system, where a three-man defence can be vulnerable to rapid transitions, the goalkeeper plays a pivotal role. He must be decisive, quick off his line, and in constant communication with his centre-backs. In this regard, Emiliano Martínez fits the profile perfectly. His anticipation, presence, and confidence under pressure make him a natural fit for such a demanding role.
However, there are risks to consider. Martínez’s emotionally charged style, while inspiring at times, can also inflame situations—particularly in a dressing room already under pressure. His tendency to lean into the mental and provocative side of the game can be a double-edged sword in the high-stakes environment of the Premier League. Additionally, at 32, he is not a long-term solution. Yet from another perspective, that same fiery personality might be exactly what United need, a strong, vocal figure capable of commanding respect and inspiring a response.
The deal remains contingent on André Onana’s departure. If he stays, Martínez won’t arrive. But if the club is prioritising immediate leadership and stability over long-term planning, Martínez is a logical and impactful choice. The debate is open and increasingly urgent.