Jean-Philippe Mateta’s transformation from a backup striker to a talismanic figure at Crystal Palace has been nothing short of remarkable. Under Oliver Glasner, the French forward finally found the rhythm and confidence that had previously eluded him in English football. The 2024/25 season saw him net 17 goals across all competitions, his most prolific campaign to date, elevating both his reputation and market value. Unsurprisingly, his resurgence has not gone unnoticed. For weeks, reports have linked him with a move to a bigger stage, with Manchester United among the clubs reportedly interested in acquiring his services.
CaughtOffside initially broke the news of United’s interest, while BBC Sport confirmed that Mateta was also attracting attention from Aston Villa and Olympique Marseille. However, the situation appears to have taken a sharp turn. According to updated reports from the UK, Mateta is now close to signing a contract extension with Crystal Palace. It’s a development that would be warmly received by Glasner, who has successfully rebuilt his attack around the Frenchman’s strengths. But for Manchester United and other suitors, it represents a clear setback, especially considering how viable the deal once looked.
From a tactical standpoint, Mateta would have fit seamlessly into the 3-4-2-1 system employed by Rúben Amorim. United’s structure requires a central striker capable of pressing high, bullying centre-backs, and linking play when needed, roles the 27-year-old has proven adept at. While not the most technically refined forward, Mateta excels at positioning, thrives on physical duels, and provides a consistent goal threat.
Manchester United might not be getting Jean-Philippe Mateta now
He would’ve offered the Red Devils a more direct and robust option ideal for breaking down low blocks and unsettling defences in tight fixtures. His contract renewal might be a minor blow in the grand scheme of United’s rebuild, but it closes the door on what could have been a clever, system-compatible acquisition.
Mateta’s non-arrival is far from a catastrophe for Manchester United. Instead, it serves as a timely reminder that the club must sharpen its transfer strategy. If they remain intent on recruiting a striker with similar attributes, the market offers compelling alternatives. RB Leipzig’s Loïs Openda brings pace, aggression, and a relentless presence in the box, traits that align with what United need. Benjamin Šeško is another name gaining traction.
More Manchester United News:
Though his price tag could prove a hurdle and Arsenal appear to have the upper hand, his physical profile and technical upside make him a worthy consideration. Both players embody the characteristics Amorim is likely seeking: a finisher who can exploit space, dominate duels, and consistently convert chances.
There’s also a broader takeaway in all this, perhaps one that speaks more to Mateta’s career arc than United’s needs. Staying at Selhurst Park may be the wisest choice for the Frenchman. Not every player thrives after making the leap to a bigger club, and Crystal Palace has given him the platform to flourish. As for United, this moment might reaffirm the value of prioritising young, ambitious talent over fully developed profiles.
Amorim’s rebuild should be anchored in players with hunger and untapped potential, not just immediate output. Losing out on Mateta doesn’t derail the plan, it simply forces a recalibration of the route forward.