The atmosphere at Manchester United is far from calm. The 2024/25 season ended with more questions than answers, and the unease has spilled into the dressing room. Several key players appear unsettled, and none more so than Alejandro Garnacho. The young Argentine, one of the few bright spots in an otherwise dreary campaign, now finds himself at the centre of mounting speculation. This is not mere tabloid chatter, his demeanour in the Europa League final, cryptic social media activity, and whispers from journalists close to his camp all point in one direction: Garnacho wants out. And he isn’t trying to hide it.
According to Gastón Edul, via TEAMtalk, Arsenal have already made contact to assess the feasibility of a deal. Chelsea, too, have registered interest, while an unnamed foreign club is said to be monitoring the situation. Yet, indications suggest Garnacho would prefer to remain in the Premier League. That puts English rivals in pole position, and Arsenal in particular are serious contenders. With Gabriel Martinelli and Leandro Trossard struggling to find consistent form on the left flank, Garnacho’s directness, flair, and raw hunger offer an ideal alternative. The Argentine thrives on beating defenders one-on-one and injecting energy into attacks—exactly what Mikel Arteta may be looking for.
Alejandro Garnacho in action, sparking transfer rumors as Arsenal eye the Manchester United winger
What is more surprising than the interest, however, is Manchester United’s willingness to entertain offers. Garnacho was one of the few constants in a turbulent campaign, and letting him go could send the wrong message about the club’s direction. Yet, if the player has made up his mind, United may be forced into a difficult decision: cash in now and reinvest, or risk an unhappy talent becoming a dressing-room distraction. Either way, the coming weeks could define the next chapter for both player and club.
When it comes to whether Manchester United should allow Alejandro Garnacho to join Arsenal, the answer isn’t straightforward. If the player no longer feels valued or part of a serious project, forcing him to stay could only worsen the situation. However, selling him to a direct rival like Arsenal is a risky move. At just 20, Garnacho has already proven he can deliver in high-pressure environments.
🚨🇦🇷 Alejandro Garnacho will leave Man United, decision confirmed on player and club side — set to part ways.
Understand staying in Premier League serious option with 3 clubs already very keen… after Bayer Leverkusen and Italian clubs calling.
🎥 More: https://t.co/xW4fi7gcBu pic.twitter.com/XCbqQlQupl
— Fabrizio Romano (@FabrizioRomano) June 7, 2025
Handing a talent like him to Mikel Arteta’s side could significantly strengthen a competitor while further weakening United in an area where they already lack depth. With Antony underperforming, Sancho out of the picture, and Rashford struggling for consistency, losing Garnacho would only expose an already vulnerable wing department.
More Manchester United News:
The core issue isn’t just Garnacho’s potential departure, it’s the way Manchester United have mismanaged the situation. If the Argentine wants to leave, the real question is: why? Did he feel sidelined? Was he not presented with a convincing long-term vision? Did he lack support within the squad? These are critical questions the club must confront, and urgently. A player with Garnacho’s talent and strong connection with the fans doesn’t become disillusioned overnight. The board should have stepped in earlier, offering dialogue, reassurance, and a clear plan for his development. Allowing him to leave without resistance would signal that the club is no longer thinking long-term.
Losing Garnacho would be a blow to the squad’s depth and attacking threat. He’s one of the few players at United willing to take on defenders, win fouls, and challenge in one-on-one situations. His exit would create a gap that can’t be filled by stop-gap signings or vague promises. From a branding perspective, letting a homegrown talent join a direct rival would be seen as weakness. And if he thrives at Arsenal, the consequences will haunt United for years.