Bruno Fernandes gave his side an early lead from the penalty spot after Amad had been fouled in the box, before Everton equalised in the lead-up to half-time when Iliman Ndiaye fired in at the back post.
Ruben Amorim made a change at half-time as Patrick Dorgu replaced Mbeumo, and United regained their lead when fellow substitute Mason Mount curled a fantastic effort in at the far post. Everton caused plenty of problems, though, and found themselves level again when Amad and Ayden Heaven combined to score a bizarre own goal.
United will face Fiorentina in their final pre-season match before the new Premier League campaign begins, and here is how we rated the players who played the majority of the Everton game.
He struggled again and didn't command the backline. A reminder he must be replaced this summer if possible.
1. Altay Bayindir - 5
He struggled again and didn't command the backline. A reminder he must be replaced this summer if possible. | Manchester United via Getty Images
A joy to watch. He has started all three US friendlies and shone in every one. He is a new undroppable in the starting line up.
2. Leny Yoro - 8
A joy to watch. He has started all three US friendlies and shone in every one. He is a new undroppable in the starting line up. | Manchester United via Getty Images
He defended well and was a physical presence in the heart of defence. He should be a starter in the new season.
3. Matthijs De Ligt - 7
He defended well and was a physical presence in the heart of defence. He should be a starter in the new season. | Manchester United via Getty Images
Everton had plenty of joy down the left and he was the weakest of their starting defenders in the match.
4. Luke Shaw - 6
Everton had plenty of joy down the left and he was the weakest of their starting defenders in the match. | Manchester United via Getty Images