It’s that time of the year again when the Royal Blue Mersey crew get together and come up with their predictions for the upcoming season in the following categories -
Premier League Top 6, Everton position, Premier League Bottom 3,FA Cup Winner, Everton FA Cup, EFL Cup Winner, Everton EFL Cup, Premier League Golden Boot Winner, Everton Golden Boot Winner, Premier League Player of the Year, Everton Player of the Year.
So here we go with the writers’ 2025/26 Premier League season predictions, let’s have your predictions in the comments section below as well, and then we can compare notes as usual at the end of the season.
Not unexpectedly, the optimism for Everton is somewhere in the middle. No one is quite expecting us to be in the hunt for Europe, but at the same time no one is calling it that we’re going to be in another relegation scrap either. The average finishing position across the group of ten fans has us at 10.4, so leading the bottom half of the table basically.
However, there appears to be some confidence that the Blues will make noise in the Carabao Cup, with three of us saying that we’ll finally break our trophy drought with a first-ever title win in the League Cup.
With all the additions to the squad and another 3-4 anticipated pick-ups, it might take well over half the season to integrate those players in which case it is hard to be optimistic. There’s little hope that the trophy drought ends this season making it 31 barren years, and almost no hope that we can make to Europe either.
Iliman Ndiaye leads the vote for top scorer for the Blues, while the race for the Toffees’ Player of the Year is a bit closer with Ndiaye picking up four votes and new signing Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall in second with three. Jack Grealish gets a couple too, with defending champion and ageless midfielder Idrissa Gueye getting one vote.
Write in your predictions below as well, and we can review next May for added hilarity!