Upon hearing the selection, Carragher erupted into laughter, which clearly irritated Neville. He asked: "Why you laughing?" prompting Carragher to respond: "You pick the Man United manager every year on that."
For the latest breaking stories and headlines, sign up to our Daily Express MUFC newsletter, or join our WhatsApp community here.
Neville replied: "I don't pick them every year, it's disrespectful," before Carragher added: "You picked three of them last year and one of them was [Erik] Ten Hag."
Defending his reasoning, the United legend explained: "The reason last year was a similar reason to this. Ten Hag last year because I knew if he started badly, he'd be under massive pressure.
"Similarly, there's probably going to be no in between here. Ruben Amorim, if he starts off badly and they're in 13th, 14th in October, November, he's going to be under massive pressure.
"He's the Manchester United manager, he has to deliver in these first few months of the season and I think he will outperform. I know you're not sure about him and you sort of wrote your article the other day saying that you think he's not that good. Well, what was your article about?"
Carragher then said: "It was about the two managers, [Mikel] Arteta and Amorim and how Amorim would be delighted if he was in Arteta's position in three or four years."