CLEVELAND, Ohio — The Cavs find themselves in an enviable position that struggling franchises can only dream about.
With their 14th roster spot still available, they’re weighing whether to pursue Malik Beasley, a proven NBA sharpshooter suddenly available at a bargain price due to off-court issues.
But the decision isn’t as straightforward as talent alone might suggest.
The Wine and Gold Talk podcast dives deep into what’s become a fascinating roster debates of the late offseason: Beasley vs. Sam Merrill.
“Would you rather have Malik Beasley or Sam Merrill?” podcast host Ethan Sands asks, framing the central tension.
The answer reveals the complexity behind NBA roster construction, where talent evaluation meets team chemistry in ways casual fans might not appreciate.
“From an on-court perspective, it’s Malik Beasley,” Chris Fedor, Cavs beat reporter for cleveland.com, stated definitively. “He’s accomplished more throughout the course of his career. He was in the sixth man of the year conversation. He was one of the bench leaders in scoring in the NBA last year. There’s just more of a reputation, there’s more of a known commodity to Malik and the kind of role that he has had throughout the course of his career.”
The statistical case for Beasley appears overwhelming.
As discussed on the podcast, Beasley was first in bench points per game (minimum 60 games), second in total 3-pointers made, and joined elite company as just the fifth player ever with 300 or more threes made in a single season. He shot a blistering 41.6% from deep while averaging 16.3 points per game off the bench for Detroit.
But the podcast conversation revealed a crucial dimension beyond the box score - team culture and development philosophy.
“I think Sam Merrill fits the Kenny system a little bit better,” Jimmy Watkins, cleveland.com columnist, explained. “It would be a little awkward for the Cavs, even if it’s the correct basketball decision, to kind of nudge one of their brightest success stories, a gem that they found developed, turned into a rotation player.”
This tension represents the evolution of the Cavaliers as an organization.
As Fedor pointed out, these are the types of decisions that signal Cleveland’s arrival as a legitimate contender: “Remember when Koby Altman talked about at his end of season press conference, you know, there’s this space that we’re now in and we like living in it and we’re comfortable living in it. These are the kinds of decisions that the Chicago Bulls don’t have these kinds of decisions to make.”
The podcast reveals how the Cavs have evolved their evaluation process beyond simplistic talent assessment to consider fit, development pathway, and organizational investment. They committed to Merrill with a new contract this offseason, reflecting their belief in his growth trajectory despite his more limited statistical production (six shots per game with 5.2 from beyond the arc).
Perhaps most telling was Fedor’s observation that the Cavs have already made their decision on Merrill: “The Cavs love Sam Merrill. They committed to him for a reason... Never in their mind did they think, we got to move on from Sam Merrill.”
What makes this podcast discussion so compelling is how it illustrates the multi-dimensional chess that contending teams must play.
A potential Beasley signing represents insurance more than replacement - protecting against the possibility that Merrill isn’t ready for an expanded role.
Want to hear the full breakdown of this fascinating roster debate and what it means for the Cavs’ championship aspirations? Listen to the complete Wine & Gold Talk podcast episode for more insider analysis on Cleveland’s most intriguing late-offseason storyline.
Here’s the podcast for this week:
If you purchase a product or register for an account through a link on our site, we may receive compensation. By using this site, you consent to our [User Agreement](https://www.advancelocal.com/advancelocalUserAgreement/user-agreement.html) and agree that your clicks, interactions, and personal information may be collected, recorded, and/or stored by us and social media and other third-party partners in accordance with our [Privacy Policy.](https://www.advancelocal.com/advancelocalUserAgreement/privacy-policy.html)