Tyler Dibling’s transfer to Everton might have surprised the football world, and fans could be concerned.
A £40 million fee for a 19-year-old who is an unproven Premier League player is always a risk, but David Moyes has faith in the youngster.
Dibling could be ‘worth every penny’ as the winger has resemblances to the likes of Jack Grealish, whom he will be playing alongside.
The plan is to keep the young star here for the long haul, as Dibling’s ceiling could reach scary heights.
Moyes will want to unlock his potential at the Hill Dickinson Stadium, but there have been questions raised about a player of his prospect only gaining a four-year contract at Everton, but it makes perfect sense.
Everton winger Tyler Dibling.
Photo by Jan Kruger/Getty Images
Tyler Dibling’s four-year contract decision at Everton could benefit PSR
The Friedkin Group have worked tirelessly to get this deal done, as at one stage Southampton demanded £50 million for the winger.
Everton’s hierarchy obviously didn’t give in and got a cheaper deal with the bonus of Dibling’s sell-on clause being less than 20%.
But there have been eyebrows raised at the youngster only gaining a four-year contract, after seeing the likes of Chelsea hand their bright talents five-year-plus deals.
MORE EVERTON STORIES
Daniel Geey, a leading sports lawyer, explains long-term contracts in football (25:30)
It turns out, there is a reason why the Toffees don’t follow the trend, and speaking to Everton.News, financial expert Adam Williams has explained why a four-year deal works in the Blues’ favour.
“For amortisation purposes, you can spread the cost of a transfer – that’s usually the basic fee plus payments to agents – over up to five years,” Williams said.
“The Dibling fee was £35m, plus about £5m in add-ons. Those add-ons aren’t typically capitalised until they arise, so we’ll leave them out of the calculation here. We also don’t know the agents’ fee, so we’ll leave that out here too.
“That £35m is being spread out for the purposes of PSR over four years, so he ‘costs’ Everton’s bottom line £8.75m every season – and it’s the bottom line which PSR is based on. If it was a five-year deal, that figure would be £7m, so their bottom line would be £1.75m better off annually. That means you have £1.75m less breathing space with PSR that could otherwise be spent elsewhere that season.
“The distinction here is that the cash impact is the same, but the bottom-line impact is smoothed out over the useful lifetime of the asset,” he added.
“From a common-sense perspective, you’re locking in Dibling’s value if you have him tied down for longer. The risk with any player is that the longer the deal, the longer you’re committed to paying a player who isn’t guaranteed to be a hit.
“With a shorter contract length, you could also generate a slightly bigger PSR profit if you sell him after, say, two years. Sale profits are calculated based on amortised book value, and because on a shorter deal his amortised book value decreases quicker, a £60-70m sale in year two would generate more profit than if he had signed a five-year deal and was sold two years in.
“Against that, the value of Dibling as an asset is likely to stay higher the more years he has on his contract, so there are competing forces there. Ordinarily, I would have suspected that the club would want the longest possible deal, but Everton have made several signings on sub-five-year deals. Carlos Alcaraz on a two-year deal, for example.
Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall Until 2030
Jarrad Branthwaite Until 2030
Mark Travers Until 2029
Tyler Dibling Until 2029
Thierno Barry Until 2029
Five of the biggest contracts currently at Everton, as per Spotrac
“Everton’s transfer amortisation was the 11th highest in the Premier League in the last financial year at £68m, down from a high of £99m in 2019-20. They have some room for manoeuvre there, offset against the new stadium revenue. But they’ll be wary of not overcommitting themselves.”
Tyler Dibling could follow the same path as Jarrad Branthwaite’s new Everton contract
So it’s clear that The Friedkins know what they’re doing with Dibling, and he could follow the same destiny as Jarrad Branthwaite.
When the central defender joined from Carlisle United for £1 million, the 22-year-old penned a three-and-a-half-year deal at Everton.
Similar to Dibling’s four-year deal, it seems the Toffees are holding out to see if the winger will be that ‘hit’ they’re looking for.
If the winger is to be that player, he could follow Jarrad Branthwaite’s new five-year contract, which is a possibility for Dibling if he isn’t sold on, as Branthwaite proved to be a certain hit.
But if it comes to the point where he is sold for a suitable fee, then it’s ultimately a win-win situation for Everton.