Manchester United’s defeat against League Two Grimsby Town in the Carabao Cup on Wednesday night has undoubtedly set a new low for Ruben Amorim during his tenure in charge.
The Red Devils were knocked out in the second round of the competition, losing on penalties after coming from two goals down in the second half.
However, it may prove to be a damning defeat for the 40-year-old, adding more pressure to his shoulders after their dismal start to the 2025/26 Premier League campaign.
Mainoo-Man-Utd-Amorim
His side have failed to win any of the first three games, which could force the hierarchy into making a change - especially after backing him with £200m worth of new additions this summer.
The window still has a few days remaining, but it remains to be seen if the former Sporting CP boss will carry on leading the side, with rumours circulating about his future at Old Trafford.
The latest on Amorim’s future at United
Over the last couple of days, it’s been reported by CaughtOffside that the United hierarchy are now considering making a change of manager, after Amorim’s disastrous start to the new season.
The report states that it’s a matter of time before the 40-year-old is handed his marching orders, with concerns around his ability to take the side forward in the future.
ruben amorim
INEOS are said to be willing to make an early decision to sack the boss, in order to avoid a repeat of last season, which saw the side finish in a measly 15th place.
The same article also states that Crystal Palace boss Oliver Glasner is being lined up as a potential replacement, if and when Amorim is dismissed from his position at Old Trafford.
It states that the FA Cup-winning boss would be keen to take the reins, potentially being the next manager in a long list to try and take the Red Devils back to their former glory.
Why United’s Amorim replacement would be Klopp 2.0
Jürgen Klopp is a manager who has caused United no end of problems over the years, often leading rivals Liverpool to countless victories over the Red Devils in the Premier League.
jurgen-klopp-club-world-cup-trophy
The German only suffered five defeats in his 21 outings against the Red Devils, even claiming a historic 7-0 victory at Anfield back in the 2022/23 campaign.
Whilst he may have managed their bitter rivals, there’s no denying the former Reds boss is a serial winner - something which United have lacked, given their decade-long wait for a top-division title.
He may be out of management after leaving Liverpool in 2024, but there is no chance he would return to management and replace Amorim - especially considering his ties with the Merseyside outfit.
However, INEOS could hire their own answer to Klopp with a move for Glasner, with the Eagles boss previously being compared to the Premier League legend by German expert Constantin Eckner.
"While Glasner had been known as a calm and even restrained manager, he seemed to come out of his shell during that Europa League run, often supporting his players through gestures and instructions with a kind of intensity akin to Jurgen Klopp."
German Football Expert Constantin Eckner on Oliver Glasner.
When comparing his stats at Selhurst Park to Amorim in England’s top-flight, he’s managed to better him in various key areas - potentially being the perfect replacement should the former Sporting CP boss depart.
oliver-glasner-crystal-palace
Oliver Glasner lifts the FA Cup.
Glasner, who’s been dubbed “incredible” by Pep Guardiola, has achieved a better win percentage than Amorim - doing so whilst having a much lower budget during his time in England.
He’s also notched a better point per game record, having the tools to change the Red Devils’ fortunes should he take the reins in the coming months.
How Glasner & Amorim's record compare in England
Statistics
Games managed
Wins
Draws
Losses
Points per game
Win percentage
Goals scored (per 90)
Goals against (per 90)
Trophies won
Stats via Transfermarkt
The Austrian’s dominance over the United boss is further reflected in his ability to build a solid defensive unit - achieving a better goal conceded per 90 record.
Amorim’s future in the role could well be coming to an end in the coming weeks, but it’s clear such a decision would be the right one after such an embarrassing showing in the Carabao Cup.
oliver glasner-1
Glasner would be an excellent replacement, already winning two trophies in recent months, having the tools to bring the glory days back to Old Trafford should he make the move.