Everton are only able to boast a win percentage of just 30.8% from their opening 13 Premier League games at the Hill Dickinson Stadium.
There is a clear distinction between Everton’s start on the Liverpool docks to how Arsenal and Tottenham started at their respective new homes, as they both won 61.5% of their opening 13 games.
Club Stadium Win Draw Loss Win % Points
Arsenal (2006/07) Emirates 8 5 0 61.5% 29
Tottenham (2019) Tottenham Stadium 8 1 4 61.5% 25
Everton (2025/26) Hill Dickinson 5 4 4 38.5% 19
West Ham (2016/17) London Stadium 4 3 6 30.8% 15
Although Everton are not battling relegation, their home form at the Hill Dickinson Stadium matches that of West Ham’s start at the London Stadium.
Bournemouth’s Ryan Christie has hailed the Hill Dickinson Stadium atmosphere, but the Blues have not won a game on home soil since early December against Nottingham Forest.
What is going so wrong at the Hill Dickinson Stadium for Everton? 😳
It is now less than one win in every three following the loss against Bournemouth… 😤
A general exterior view of Hill Dickinson Stadium ahead of the Premier League match between Everton and Bournemouth.
Credit: Getty Images/Robbie Jay Barratt – AMA.
Considering Everton only sit eight points off fourth spot, it has become clear just how much their form at the Hill Dickinson Stadium is hindering their season.
Everton v Sunderland - Emirates FA Cup Third Round
Photo by Carl Recine/Getty Images
Everton are struggling since Hill Dickinson Stadium move
A number of Everton fans have shared their frustrations at the Hill Dickinson Stadium’s transport links, which have caused a lot of disruption after games.
MORE EVERTON STORIES
However, it is the football inside the stadium that is really concerning.
Everton have gone without a win in their last six Premier League games at the Hill Dickinson Stadium, drawing games against the likes of Wolves and Leeds United.
What do you miss most about Goodison Park after months in the Hill Dickinson Stadium? 🥺
The new stadium has surpassed all expectations so far 🔥
Gary Neville quote on Goodison Park's shaky gantry.
Credit: Getty Images/Matt McNulty.
Dan Meis designed the Hill Dickinson Stadium with 55-degree stands to make the atmosphere as intimidating as possible for visiting teams.
That has not really been seen after the opening 13 Premier League games, with Everton having only beaten the following sides on home soil:
Brighton & Hove Albion
Crystal Palace
Fulham
Nottingham Forest
Moyes has collected more away points at Everton than any other manager in the Premier League, since he returned to Merseyside last January.
Everton’s away form has been exemplary, but it is at home where the Blues have really struggled to capitalise.
Everton’s European hopes are fading amid dreadful Hill Dickinson Stadium form
Moyes really wants Everton to push for the European spots this season, with Everton’s away form proving more than good enough.
The Blues have won away at Old Trafford and in other big away games, but Everton have not been able to secure such a big victory on home soil.
Next up for Everton is a game against Manchester United at the Hill Dickinson, where Moyes will have an opportunity to make a real statement towards European qualification.
A win for the Toffees would see them close the gap down to just five points on United, who sit in the final Champions League spot currently.
Join Our Newsletter
Receive a digest of our best Everton content each week direct to your mailbox