Injury-hit Sunderland show character to seal derby double as boos greet Newcastle players at St James’s Park
There are derby wins, and then there are generational derby wins. Sunderland’s victory over Newcastle United at St James’s Park on Sunday belongs firmly in the latter category.
It was not meant to unfold like this - not with the injury list Sunderland carried into Tyneside. No Robin Roefs. No Dan Ballard. No Nordi Mukiele. No Enzo Le Fée. No Reinildo. No Bertrand Traoré. No Romaine Mundle. No Jocelin Ta Bi. A patched-up side, away from home, facing opponents who have spent heavily and operated from a position of Premier League strength for years. And yet, here Sunderland were again.
For the second time this season, they had beaten their Saudi-backed, oil-rich neighbours. The disparity in resources, so often used as shorthand for expectation, felt irrelevant. Newcastle’s £250million summer spend sat alongside Sunderland’s £150million investment following promotion - and still it was Régis Le Bris’ side who found the decisive edge. That increasingly feels like his imprint. Le Bris, the pragmatist. Le Bris, the problem-solver. Play-off semi-final, play-off final, and now two derby wins. When the stakes rise, his teams tend to respond.
When the spotlight sharpens, his teams tend to hold their nerve. Sunderland are safe on 43 points and, in truth, have been for some time - certainly since that draw with Manchester City on New Year’s Day, the point where survival felt more than probable. What he has done with this group should not be underestimated. It is a talented squad, yes, but an imperfect one. There are clear issues in the attacking third that still need refining. That will come. What already exists is structure, belief and adaptability - all of which were required after an early and calamitous set-back.
The afternoon developed revealed plenty. Sunderland fell behind early after Luke O’Nien’s error - the kind of moment that can derail an afternoon before it has begun. It did not. The reaction was measured rather than frantic, composed rather than chaotic. O’Nien himself embodied that shift, recovering to deliver a commanding second-half display that spoke volumes about the mentality inside this squad.
Because that is the defining characteristic of this group: resilience. Write them off at your peril. After Port Vale, after Brighton, there were familiar murmurs in certain corners. Yet this team has made a habit of absorbing setbacks and answering them. Chris Rigg’s performance felt like a line being drawn. At 18, in a derby of this magnitude, the local lad did not retreat into the background. He imposed himself on the biggest stage of his career.
Around him, others rose to the occasion. Omar Alderete, operating within an unfamiliar back four, remained unflappable. Lutsharel Geertruida refused to let deeply difficult circumstances distract him. Brian Brobbey led the line tirelessly, his reward arriving late on with the winning goal - the latest ever decisive strike in a Premier League meeting between these sides. Despite the injuries, despite the uncertainty, despite the pressure and unfamiliar combinations, Sunderland grew into the game. The numbers reinforce that point. Newcastle had more of the ball, finishing with 60 per cent possession, but Sunderland carried the greater threat. An expected goals return of 2.45 to 1.27, more shots on target, more clarity in the final third. Control where it mattered.
Zoom out and the wider pattern becomes undeniable. Sunderland are now unbeaten in 11 league games against Newcastle United. The Magpies have not won a league derby since 2011, nor at St James’s Park since 2010. The double has been secured for the first time since 2014-15. Chemsdine Talbi’s goal saw him become the youngest Sunderland player to score against Newcastle in the Premier League at 20 years and 317 days. For Newcastle, the fragility remains. No side in the Premier League has dropped more points from winning positions this season - 22 now - and another lead slipped away.
Before kick-off, the home end unveiled a banner referencing Sunderland’s recent past in the third tier. A message of superiority, or so it seemed. By full-time, the mood had turned on its head. It was the 2,000 Sunderland supporters laughing inside St James’s Park, not the 50,000 Tynesiders - many of whom met the final whistle with boos aimed at their own players. Sunderland, aligned from ownership to manager to squad to supporters, are building something far more meaningful than survival. Sunday reinforced a simple truth: when everyone pulls in the same direction, this club becomes a serious force. Right now, Wearside is the footballing “capital” of the North East.
Continue Reading