Newcastle United have posted their first profit since their Saudi-backed takeover after restructuring ownership of St James’ Park, pushing commercial revenue beyond £100m despite a £109.4m operating loss. Celtic, by contrast, remain profitable through traditional income streams, but the real comparison is not about method, it is about ambition.
Newcastle’s latest accounts show how far a club will go to expand its financial position. Internal restructuring has turned asset movement into reported revenue, strengthening their ability to spend within league rules.
Newcastle United sold St James' Park to themselves.
🔲 Arrangement led to first profit since Saudi-led takeover
🔲 Joined Big Six in topping £100m of annual commercial revenue
🔲 Operating loss hit a club record £109.4m
Newcastle's 2024-25 filings show that ownership of the… pic.twitter.com/bs5cpfldDP
— The Athletic | Football (@TheAthleticFC) March 31, 2026
View Tweet
Celtic have built their model on a self-sustaining foundation. The Bhoys remain profitable through traditional income streams such as domestic prize money, merchandise deals, Champions League participation and a successful player-trading model.
That contrast is often framed as right versus wrong. The more relevant question is how far Celtic and Newcastle are prepared to push the pursuit of progress.
The first thing I would do if I was on the Celtic board is – – – –
Dermot Desmond arrives at Celtic Park
Dermot Desmond arrives at Celtic Park Credit: Getty Images/Ian MacNicol
Newcastle’s approach shows what ambition looks like in the modern game
The main headline is that Newcastle posted their first profit since takeover. The context is more revealing, with commercial revenue beyond £100m alongside a £109.4m operating loss.
This is a deliberate move. The sale of the stadium to themselves has been structured in a way that increases room to spend, even when the core football operation remains loss-making.
MORE CELTIC STORIES
The point is not whether Celtic should replicate that approach. It is that Newcastle are using every available mechanism to accelerate growth and close the gap to the top level.
Celtic do not need financial engineering, but they do need to act
Celtic’s financial position is strong without internal restructuring. The club operates profitably and continues to generate income through its football model.
However, that strength creates a different challenge. Stability has been achieved, but it does not automatically translate into competitive progress against clubs in Europe increasing their spending capacity.
Celtic already have the resources to be more assertive in Europe. The question is whether those resources are being used with enough intent to match the demands of the European progression Celtic fans demand.
Celtic do not need to copy Newcastle’s methods. They may need to match their willingness to push forward, because ambition is now measured by what clubs choose to do with their strength, not just how they protect it.
Join Our Newsletter
Receive a digest of our best Celtic content each week direct to your mailbox