McCabe’s time at Meadow Park and the Emirates Stadium has been defined by an incredible collection of team honours. During her 11 years with the club, the versatile full-back won one FA Cup, one Women's Super League title, three League Cups, and reached the pinnacle of European football by winning the Women’s Champions League in May 2025.
Her final season saw her complete the set of available honours, following a FIFA Champions Cup victory in February 2026. This final trophy ensured that McCabe leaves the Gunners having won every major club competition possible during her stay, cementing her legacy as one of the most successful players to ever pull on the red and white shirt.