Granit Xhaka had some harsh words after Switzerland's World Cup dream ended in a 3-1 extra-time defeat to Argentina, with Breel Embolo's controversial dismissal for simulation the moment that changed everything.
Embolo was sent off in the 71st minute after referee Joao Pinheiro was sent to the pitch-side monitor to review a challenge involving Leandro Paredes. Paredes had initially been booked for the foul, but the review under the "mistaken identity" protocol saw that yellow rescinded and a second one shown to the Swiss forward instead, ruled to have dived.
Switzerland played the remainder of normal time and all of extra-time with 10 men.
Xhaka: "You Kill the Game"
Granit Xhaka vs ArgentinaJay Biggerstaff (IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters)
The Swiss captain's frustration was obvious when he faced the media after the final whistle. "The rules are the rules," Xhaka said, "but it's a decision where you kill the game in my opinion." It was a measured but pointed response from the Sunderland midfielder, who watched his side's numerical disadvantage prove decisive over the remaining hour of football.
Granit Xhaka, Xherdan Shaqiri and Stephan Lichtsteiner all in Swiss kit with Swiss theme Related
15 Greatest Switzerland Players in Football History [Ranked]
So many of these have played in the current 'golden generation' of Swiss stars.
Switzerland had just drawn level through Nottingham Forest's Dan Ndoye moments before Embolo's red card, and looked the more dangerous side in the immediate aftermath, only for the sending off to swing momentum firmly back in Argentina's favour.
Julian Alvarez and Lautaro Martinez both scored in extra-time to complete the turnaround, with Xhaka's post-match comments reflecting a wider sense in the Swiss camp that the result had been shaped by the officials as much as by events on the pitch.
See what Xhaka had to say below:
Christina Unkel Delivers Interesting Verdict
Breel Embolo vs ArgentinaDenny Medley (IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters)
The debate didn't end with Xhaka. Former FIFA referee Christina Unkel drew a direct line between Embolo's dismissal and a near-identical incident involving Miguel Almiron in the United States' opening group game with Paraguay, arguing FIFA is using the mistaken identity framework to disguise a different kind of intervention entirely.
"Embolo decision is consistent with Almiron decision," she wrote. "FIFA is treating these situations as mistaken identity but it’s really 'Simulation' VAR can recommend. The controversial part is VAR is not just changing the player but is changing the offence. We are in re-refereeing zone."
The comparison has gathered traction online, with both incidents following the same pattern: an initial card for a foul, a VAR review, and a reversal that punishes the player deemed to have gone down rather than the one who made contact.