Why Joshua Zirkzee exit could reopen Man Utd striker search
Joshua Zirkzee appears closer to leaving Manchester United, and his departure would leave Michael Carrick with another decision to make before the transfer window closes.
Juventus are continuing talks with United and Zirkzee’s representatives over a return to Serie A. Gianluca Di Marzio reports that United have now opened the door to a loan, while Matteo Moretto says they would still prefer either a permanent transfer or a loan containing an obligation to buy. Zirkzee is understood to be open to joining Juventus.
That is a significant change. ReadManUtd reported on Wednesday that Juventus are ready to push towards completing a deal for Zirkzee after United had previously been reluctant to weaken Carrick’s attacking options.
🚨🎙️ | Fabrizio Romano on Joshua Zirkzee's potential exit from #MUFC:
"For the FIRST time, Zirkzee is genuinely LOOKING AROUND regarding his future unlike before.
"He would happily RETURN to Italy. He enjoyed his time there and knows the league."
[@Utdtruthful] pic.twitter.com/ExX4sZa2p1
— (fan) Frank 🧠🇾🇪 (@FrankEra_) August 5, 2026
Zirkzee exit would leave Man Utd short centrally
Benjamin Sesko remains United’s leading centre-forward, but he has yet to feature during pre-season because of a shin problem.
Bryan Mbeumo has filled the position effectively. He scored twice against Atletico Madrid and gives Carrick another option through the middle, but using him there also removes one of United’s strongest wide attackers.
That is one of the questions Carrick needs to resolve against Paris Saint-Germain. ReadManUtd’s PSG preview highlighted the decision over who should lead the Manchester United attack, with Sesko still building towards his first appearance of the summer.
Zirkzee has never established himself as a regular starter at Old Trafford. Football Italia records nine goals from 75 appearances across his first two seasons, and his previous success with Bologna makes Italy an obvious destination.
His departure would still reduce United’s numbers.
Carrick could use Mbeumo or Matheus Cunha centrally when Sesko is unavailable, but neither was recruited primarily to provide traditional centre-forward depth.
Man Utd do not need another expensive number nine
Replacing Zirkzee would not necessarily require another major transfer.
United already have a clear first choice in Sesko. What they would need is a forward prepared to compete for minutes, start cup matches and offer a different option when games require it.
That could allow United to target a less expensive or more experienced striker rather than committing another large part of the budget to the position.
The timing matters because United are also attempting to strengthen at left-back and continue assessing their midfield options.
Selling Zirkzee could create financial room. It would also create another squad vacancy that cannot simply be ignored.
For United, the Juventus talks are therefore about more than deciding Zirkzee’s future.
If he leaves, Carrick must decide whether the attacking options already at Old Trafford are enough.
James Chettle is a journalism graduate from the University of Liverpool with a strong passion for football and digital sports media. A lifelong Chelsea supporter, James manages dedicated social media pages for fellow Blues fans, giving him a close understanding of supporter culture and the conversations that matter most to audiences. Alongside his Chelsea-focused work, he writes across the Dave.Sport network, covering West Ham United, Arsenal, Brighton & Hove Albion, Aston Villa, Crystal Palace and Manchester United. His journalism spans breaking news, transfers, match analysis and the wider stories shaping clubs across the Premier League.
View all articles →
dave.sport is in beta
We are building a new home for independent sports coverage. dave.sport is currently in beta, with new features and publisher tools rolling out as we test what fans need most.
Explore the beta
Five Man Utd questions Michael Carrick must answer against PSG
Five Man Utd questions Michael Carrick must answer against PSG
Why Shea Lacey is giving Michael Carrick a Man Utd dilemma
Why Shea Lacey is giving Michael Carrick a Man Utd dilemma