Manchester City player ratings vs Manchester United
ChatGPT Image Sep 13, 2026 at 11_33_51 PM
Manchester City produced a remarkable derby win on Sunday, beating Manchester United 1-0 after Phil Foden’s 23rd-minute red card left them with ten men. Manchester City player ratings vs Manchester United now centre on a superb collective effort, with Erling Haaland settling the contest in the 60th minute and Gianluigi Donnarumma making a superb stoppage-time save from Bryan Mbeumo. City now have four wins from four league games.
Gianluigi Donnarumma — 8/10
Commanded his box, claimed crosses cleanly and stayed alert behind a defence under pressure. His late stop from Mbeumo preserved the clean sheet when United created their best chance.
Matheus Nunes — 6/10
Nunes concentrated on defending rather than attacking. He kept his position, handled Rashford’s runs and made a clean tackle inside the area.
Rúben Dias — 7/10
Dias gave City authority at centre-back, winning challenges, clearing danger and organising those around him. United asked plenty after the red card, yet Dias rarely looked rattled.
Marc Guéhi — 7/10
Guéhi attacked aerial balls and read passes before they became dangerous. His positioning helped keep United’s forwards away from useful spaces.
Joško Gvardiol — 8/10
A fine display from Gvardiol. He worked hard down the flank, defended aggressively and supplied the delivery that led to Haaland’s winner. The cross took a deflection, but he created the decisive opening.
Enzo Fernández — 8/10
Fernández controlled midfield after City lost a man, keeping possession moving. He carried the ball through pressure and nearly scored when his effort struck the post.
Elliot Anderson — 8/10
Anderson covered enormous ground and became more influential as the match wore on. He closed passing lanes, competed for loose balls and helped City protect the centre. His display earned strong praise.
Phil Foden — 3/10
Foden ruined his evening in the 23rd minute after Michael Oliver showed him a straight red for kicking out at Bruno Fernandes. However controversial the incident looked, Foden left his teammates with a huge defensive burden.
Rayan Cherki — 5/10
Cherki struggled to influence the match once City lost their numerical advantage. He tracked back when required but offered little attacking threat before leaving at half-time.
Antoine Semenyo — 6/10
Semenyo gave City an outlet during United’s pressure spells, using his strength to hold defenders off, win fouls and carry the ball into safer areas.
Erling Haaland — 8/10
Haaland supplied the moment that mattered. He arrived at the far post, finished from Gvardiol’s cross and celebrated after VAR overturned the offside call. It was his ninth Premier League goal in eight appearances against United.
Manchester City player ratings vs Manchester United: Substitutes
Iliman Ndiaye — 7/10
Ndiaye replaced Cherki at half-time and brought extra running. He tracked runners, helped protect the flanks and gave City energy without the ball.
Nico O’Reilly — 6/10
O’Reilly entered late for Fernández and helped City close midfield spaces. He kept his discipline and contested second balls during United’s final push.
Manchester City player ratings vs Manchester United show how much grit the visitors needed after Foden’s dismissal. City absorbed pressure, kept their shape and still found a winner through Haaland, while Donnarumma produced the save that mattered most. United struck the woodwork twice, but City kept their nerve and claimed the points.