emery carragher man utd
emery carragher man utd
View 4 Images
It was the sort of innocuous, run-of-the-mill opinion football fans hear all the time.
The dismal form of Manchester United this season has seen all sort of names bandied around as possible replacements for Michael Carrick and Jamie Carragher, in his role as a Sky Sports pundit, suggested Unai Emery.
Cue a gigantic - and understandable - backlash from Villa fans and a ridiculous and over-the-top response from the club and Villa chairman Nassef Sawiris, who threatened Carragher with legal action for his "unacceptable insults".
The row is still bubbling away in the background, via Emery's firm suggestion that Villa can challenge for the Champions League after Carragher revisited the topic in his weekly newspaper column.
Carragher said it was "beyond doubt" that United eclipse Villa on every conceivable metric. "It did not strike me as controversial to suggest that when a club of United’s size wants Aston Villa’s managers or players, traditionally they get them," he wrote.
That, of course, is true. The financial power of the Premier League's traditional elite, their history and offers of playing in European competitions and winning trophies do usually tempt prospective targets.
But what Carragher perhaps fails to gauge is that his viewpoint is now out of date. Like a jar that has been forgotten about at the back of the fridge, it needs chucking out and replacing with something fresher.
United are no longer the powerhouse of their Sir Alex Ferguson glory days. And they don't have their pick of the best players and managers from the Premier League and beyond.
Michael Carrick
Michael Carrick's side are far from what they once were(Image: Getty Images)
View 4 Images
This summer, they spent £155million to sign Youri Tielemans from Villa, Andrey Santos from Chelsea and Carlos Baleba from Brighton. They didn't exactly have to fight off rival clubs for their signatures - and we've seen why in the last few months.
These are middle-shelf players at best. Premium, top-shelf ones are heading elsewhere. With the Glazers piling up debts and Sir Jim Ratcliffe slashing costs wherever he can, United are unwilling or unable to shop at the same stores as their rivals.
It's a similar picture when it comes to managers. Since Ferguson retired in 2013, they have had 11 permanent or interim bosses. Five, including Carrick, have been former United players. Just two, Louis van Gaal and Jose Mourinho, could be described as proven, elite managers.
Unai Emery, head coach of Aston Villa,
Unai Emery has big ambitions at Aston Villa and is not interested in joining Manchester United(Image: Javier Borrego/Getty Images)
View 4 Images
The last two permanent bosses before Carrick show United's current level: Erik ten Hag and Ruben Amorim were hired after encouraging form with Ajax and Sporting Lisbon respectively. As the connection with Emery - who is about to sign a new contract with Villa - shows, United are simply unable to cherry-pick the best in the business.
In 2024, United chiefs spoke with Thomas Tuchel and Gareth Southgate as they pondered replacements for Ten Hag. Neither wanted the job.
The list of prospective replacements for Carrick showed the situation clearly. Emery and Brighton's Fabian Hurzeler are unattainable. Julian Nagelsmann is at a career lull after a World Cup exit with Germany. Antonio Conte is a nuclear option not many other clubs are willing to take.
Jason Wilcox and Omar Berrada
Jason Wilcox and Omar Berrada have been unable to hire a top-tier replacement for Michael Carrick(Image: Getty Images)
View 4 Images
In the Goldilocks analogy, Eddie Howe - a former Bournemouth and Newcastle boss - is just right. If they had managed to woo an elite manager then the truth is that Carrick would be long gone.
This harsh reality will be visible to all on Sunday at Old Trafford when Emery takes his Villa side to play United. Villa may arrive on the back of a 3-0 mauling by Barcelona, while United are buoyed by a 3-2 comeback win over Roma.
But as the odds show, nobody would be surprised to see Villa follow in the footsteps of Bournemouth by leaving with all three points. Emery is perfectly happy where he is with good reason.
Join our new MAN UTD WhatsApp communityand receive your daily dose of Manchester United content from Mirror Football. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice.